Google finds itself in a daunting position on Feb. 22, the third birthday of Google Apps Premier Edition. The company is trying to dislodge legacy on-premises installations from Microsoft and IBM while fighting off SAAS solutions from those same companies. It also has to compete with new cloud offerings from Cisco Systems, as well as from a slew of startups such as Zoho, MindTouch and others. But Google, Microsoft and IBM will be the main protagonists in the battle for pre-eminence in the market for cloud, or Web-based, collaboration software.
When Google launched its
Google Apps Premier Edition to the market three
years ago, it marked a bold bet on the future of collaboration software.
The collaboration software market was, and still is, ruled by Microsoft and IBM,
which boast more than 650 million customers for their respective Microsoft
Office, SharePoint and IBM Lotus suite
combined. Microsoft and IBM also license
these suites as "on-premises" software that customers install and maintain on
their own servers.
Google's launch of
was a departure from this on-premises model, offering collaboration
software hosted on Google's servers and delivered via the Web in a method that
has become known as cloud computing.
It was Google's stated intention to make money from GAPE. Until the introduction
of GAPE, Google Apps was available in a free standard edition that included
Gmail, Google Docs word processing, spreadsheet and presentation software.
However, for $50 per user per year, companies could offer their knowledge
workers GAPE, which included those apps plus additional storage, security and,
perhaps most importantly, 24/7 support.
Google Apps, which now has more than two million business customers, ranging
from one-man shops to large companies, is designed to appeal to small companies
that need low-cost collaboration software but don't have the resources to
manage it, as well as to larger enterprises that want to eliminate the expense
of managing collaboration applications themselves. This new cloud approach was
something neither Microsoft nor IBM were
aggressively pursuing at the time.
But by 2009, both Microsoft and IBM had
released hosted collaboration solutions to keep Google Apps from being the lone
wolf in cloud collaboration. Microsoft's Business Productivity Office Suite and
IBM's LotusLive mark those companies'
serious forays into the cloud.
Google finds itself in a daunting position on Monday, Feb. 22, the third
birthday of GAPE. The company is trying to dislodge legacy on-premises
installations from Microsoft and IBM while
fighting off SAAS (software-as-a-service) solutions from those same companies,
as well as new cloud offerings from Cisco Systems and from a slew of startups
such as Zoho, Mindtouch and others.
Google Enterprise President Dave Girouard said that while Google spent 2007
and 2008 arguing the benefits of the cloud, Microsoft and IBM
helped validate the market with their products.
"We now have all major competitors in our industry in full agreement
that the cloud is worth going to," Girouard said. "We view this as a
good thing. If you have all of the major vendors suggesting you look at the
cloud, the consideration of our solutions is going to rise dramatically."
Girouard, who promised big things for Google Apps in 2010
, said Google
believes it is the only "fluent, native speaker in the cloud" and
that Microsoft and IBM came into its jungle.
"We think we're several years ahead of any of them."
Customers who voted with their wallets, such as the city of Los
Angeles, Capgemini and Genentech, would seem to agree
with Girouard. For example, Brent Hoag, director of IT for cleaning product
company JohnsonDiversey, said he shuttled 12,000 employees to Google Apps from IBM
Lotus Notes and Microsoft Outlook because of insufficient storage capabilities.
"They're constantly archiving and getting messages that they can't send
or receive e-mail anymore because they filled up their mailbox after three big
attachments," Hoag said. Lotus Notes and Outlook were also slow, he found.
Hoag said he was able to port JohnsonDiversey e-mail users spread across 70
countries over to Google Apps in 48 hours.
Canadian hotel company Delta Hotels and Resorts migrated 8,000 employees
from 44 locations to Google Apps. Subash Raman, project lead for digital
innovation at Delta, said he moved workers to Google Apps from Exchange because
of storage limitations and costs. Where Microsoft offers storage inbox loads in
the megabytes, GAPE offers 25 gigabytes per inbox for each worker.
"It cost a lot to upgrade your storage," Raman said of Exchange.
Moreover, he said, "you had to build a lot of folders to keep your
conversations together and it took a lot of time to organize it. ... The new
solutions are trying to do all of those things, but Google does it