What does the Linux community make of Apple's announcement that it will be bringing XP to the Mac? Essentially: "Good for them, but it's not going to bother us much."
BOSTONLinux users and movers and shakers at LinuxWorld here were more bemused than anything else by Apples surprise announcement that it will be supporting Microsofts Windows XP on its Intel-based Macs
, in addition to the Apple Mac OS X.
Linux, which can run on Intels EFI (extensible firmware interface), was a relatively easy port to the Intel-powered Mac
. In only a matter of weeks, Linux was running on the new Macs
Microsoft, on the other hand, pulled back from supporting EFI in Vista
recently. Now, with Apples Boot Camp, users will be able to choose between XP and Mac OS X at boot time.
One LinuxWorld attendee, who is a J2EE (Java 2 Platform, Enterprise Edition) middleware developer for a Fortune 500 company, wondered why Apple would make such a move. "Why should an app developer write for both Mac OS X and Windows if he doesnt have to?" he asked.
What shape is Apples Boot Camp Assistant Beta in? Click here to read the review by eWEEK Labs.
Kevin Carmony, CEO and president of consumer Linux desktop distributor Linspire
, thinks he knows the answer: "Steve [Jobs, Apples CEO,] makes money from selling Macs and iPods. Apple is a hardware business. He doesnt care what runs on them.
"If this expands Apples market, and I think it will, thats all for the good," he said.
As for what the move might do to the burgeoning Linux desktop market, Carmony doesnt think it will have much, if any, effect. "Macs are high-end, high-price systems. Linspires systems start at $199," he said.
In addition, "95 percent of Windows users have never installed Windows. Users use the operating system that the machine boots with," said Carmony. "I dont care how many people download Linspire or buy our boxes in the stores. What I care about is how many people bought a computer with Linspire on it."
New virtualization software will let users run Windows XP or Linux together on the desktop of an Intel-based Mac. Click here to read more.
Thus, Carmony doesnt believe this move by Apple will make that much of a difference. What would make a difference, from where he sits, is if Apple made it possible to run Mac OS X on any Intel-based PC.
Jeremy White, CEO of CodeWeavers
, the company that uses Wine
to enable Linux users to run Windows applications, was surprised by Apples move. "Yah, pretty radical," said White.
CodeWeavers has been working to bring Windows applications to Intel-based Macs
. Since Mac OS X is based, in part, on the open-source FreeBSD operating system, this was a logical move for CodeWeavers.
Now, however, White said, "sadly, itll take a bit of the buzz out of our own Mac product launch [which is coming soon], but what the heck, we compete with dual booting on Linux OK."
Hes said hes "not sure" what the overall effect Apples move will have on CodeWeavers and the Linux desktop, but "I hope it means more people buy Macs; I crave a world with far more OS diversity than we have today."
Check out eWEEK.coms for the latest news in desktop and notebook computing.