Opinion: The feds are starting to get the hang of Whois commands, PayPal payments and tracking IP addresses. Can they keep ahead of the pack?
When federal authorities started unsealing court documents on April 4 about the Secret Services Operation Rolling Stone, they also gave a peek inside how they are trying to combat cyber-crime.
Although the operations name is unfortunatethe last thing Homeland Security wants to do is project the image of an aging rock band trying to keep up with much younger audiencesthe feds efforts are encouraging.
As eWEEK has detailed, the Secret Service probe is a concerted effort by the feds to start to publicly tout that they can be 21st Century crime fighters.
Perhaps some of the announcement was more PR than prosecution, though, with one prosecution source conceding, "Despite the Secret Service statement, this is just a bunch of totally unrelated cases that theyve bunched together and called Operation Rolling Stone."
But whether law enforcement has figured out Web procedures may be small comfort when other parts of the government, the banking community and private businesses still treat security lightly and with utter apathy for cyber-crime efforts.
Consider one of the cases. Shawn Mimbs, 27, was arrested by the Secret Service and is now being prosecuted by the Los Angeles District Attorneys office.
Mimbs is accused of grand theft of U.S. property. Specifically, L.A. officials are charging that he went to public libraries and Internet cafes and used their Web access to visit the H&R Block tax return service Web site.
Once on the H&R Block site, he used stolen Social Security numbers and addressesoften from dead peopleto file bogus tax returns and request that the tax refunds be wired to bank cash cards that he could access.
Deputy L.A. District Attorney Jeff McGrath, who is handling the case, said Mimbs took advantage of several loopholes.
Click here to read more about Operation Rolling Stone.
What loopholes? First, the H&R Block site didnt sufficiently authenticate new taxpayer clients who only appear online. Secondly, the IRS system was not matching its records with death certificates. And some banksin this case, it was the Stillwater National Bank in Oklahoma and the West Suburban Bank in Illinoisallow cash card accounts to be opened with insufficient authentication and then issue cards with no names on them.
So we have the federal government itselfthe IRS, which should be the king of suspicionand major banks with lax procedures. The IRS also is willing to wire funds to an unknown account.
H&R Block should also know better. Its used to the days when people came to its local storefronts and it was wonderfully personal. With the anonymity of the Web, extensive authentication is necessary. Will it be inconvenient? Certainly, but not nearly as inconvenient as letting customers get ripped off.
A fascinating part of the court documents unsealed April 4 was the peek inside the fake-credit-card world that they offered. Of the several sites mentioned in our story, my personal favorite was www.iaaca.com, which court papers identify as standing for the International Association for the Advancement of Criminal Activity.
That has simply got
to be right up there with James Bonds SPECTRE (Special Executor for Counter-Intelligence, Terrorism, Revenge and Extortion) and Get Smarts KAOS.
Ziff Davis Media eSeminars invite: Is your enterprise network truly secure? Join us April 11 at 4 p.m. ET as Akonix demonstrates best practices for neutralizing threats and securing your network.
But the procedures the feds are using are quite serious. However, a close look at six of the seven cases revealed this weekone of them appears to still be sealedsuggests what any fan of murder mysteries already knows: Stupidity on the crooks part is much more likely to solve a case than an investigators brilliance.
Example: The Secret Service agents were quite skilled at tracing IP addresses and using clues in conversations to figure out the evil-doers. The ability to issue subpoenas to the likes of Microsoft or AOLto pierce the secrecy of a Hotmail account or AOL IM talkercertainly helps, too.
But it was usually careless comments by suspects that actually revealed themselves. One suspect wanted to be paid by eBays PayPal, but the Secret Service undercover investigator told him that PayPal "was malfunctioning" and to use Western Union instead.
PayPals malfunctioning? It didnt occur to the cyber-bandit to say, "Wait a few hours and try again"? If youre engaging in wire fraud and asking for money from a faceless stranger, wouldnt the suggestion of going to Western Union seem odd?
One suspect even volunteered to not use an anonymous method, but wanted it sent to his real name. Its hard for the feds to take too many bows when the crooks are that trusting.
Or consider that Mimbs case in L.A. again. He is accused of using the names of dead people and submitting tax returns for them and collecting their refunds. How was he caught? Some of the names he used were actually associated with live people who were also filing real tax returns. (Note to cyber-bandits in training: A caper that works well with dead people may not work as well if the person just has a cold.)
Or another defendant who went through great pains to keep his credit card creation company efforts secret, but proceeded to buy much of his equipment publicly on eBayusing the same name
he used for deceptions. Correction: He changed one letter. (Second note to cyber-bandits in training: This is not
a job for the lazy.)
The Secret Service has its hands full chasing cyber-bandits who are often much better funded than the feds are. But as long as many of the suspects are this cavalier, we may just have an edge. Then again, banks and merchants are trying to give the edge back to the bandits.
Evan Schuman is retail editor for Ziff Davis Internets Enterprise Edit group. He has tracked high-tech issues since 1987, has been opinionated long before that and doesnt plan to stop anytime soon. He can be reached at Evan_Schuman@ziffdavis.com.
Check out eWEEK.coms for the latest news, views and analysis on technologys impact on retail.