FCC Expands Early Termination Fee Probe

By Roy Mark  |  Posted 2010-01-26 Print this article Print

title=CTIA, Free Press Respond}

CTIA, the trade association for major wireless carriers, quickly responded to the FCC inquiry.

"While we understand that the FCC's Consumer Task Force is only looking into the issue of early termination fees, we hope that there is a recognition by the FCC that these fees are part of the ... rate structure that allows wireless carriers to, among other things, subsidize phone purchases," the association said in a statement.

"Additionally, consumers of all of the carriers that received letters from the FCC have multiple options when it comes choosing plans and devices without early termination fees. About 20 percent of Americans have chosen a prepaid plan without a contract. It is also important to note that consumers can avoid ETFs by completing the contract terms."

Free Press, the digital rights group, praised the FCC for pressing the carriers on ETFs.

"The FCC should be cheered for continuing to press for more information about the widespread anticompetitive practice of restricting consumer freedom through shockingly high early termination fees. Consumers should not have to pay $350-or more-to cancel a bad service, but the harm is even greater when this penalty comes as a surprise," Free Press Policy Counsel Chris Riley said in a statement. "The FCC is right to express concern that disclosure of these penalties and their justification follows no clear format. We urge the FCC to clarify that the 'discount' offered on devices should be measured relative to the wholesale price of the device and not to the artificial, meaningless and uncompetitive 'retail price.'"

Late in 2009, four U.S. senators, led by Sen. Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota, introduced legislation to set limits on ETFs. The Cell Phone Early Termination Fee, Transparency and Fairness Act would prevent wireless carriers from charging an ETF that is higher than the discount on the cell phone that the company offers consumers for entering into a multiyear contract. For example, if a wireless consumer enters into a two-year contract and receives a $150 discount with the contract, the ETF cannot exceed $150.

The legislation would also require wireless carriers to prorate their ETFs for consumers who leave contracts early so that the ETF for a two-year contract would be reduced by half after one year and prorated down to zero by the end of the contract term. In addition, the bill would mandate that wireless carriers provide "clear and conspicuous disclosure" of the ETF at the time of purchase.


Submit a Comment

Loading Comments...
Manage your Newsletters: Login   Register My Newsletters

Rocket Fuel