|
|
|

High Court Agrees to Hear ATandT-ISP Dispute
By: Roy Mark
2008-06-25
Article Rating:    / 3
There are 3 user comments on this IT Infrastructure story.
California broadband provider claims AT&T engaged in antitrust actions by setting unreasonably high wholesale rates.When the Federal Communications Commission classified DSL as an information service in 2005, it put telephone broadband providers in the same category as cable modem broadband providers. The decision relieved both telephone and cable companies from legal obligations to lease broadband lines to competitors.
More importantly, telephone companies would not face the same antitrust laws that required dial-up carriers to lease their lines at a discount to independent dial-up companies. Or did it?
The Supreme Court decided June 23 to hear a case pitting California broadband provider linkLine against AT&T. The company, which leases broadband lines and resells broadband access to consumers, claims AT&T's wholesale broadband prices are so high, linkLine was unable to compete against AT&T's retail prices.
In the legalese of the case, linkLine accused AT&T of a "price squeeze" in violation of the Sherman act. The case was originally filed against Pacific Bell, which was later acquired by SBC, which, in turn, acquired AT&T and began to operate under the AT&T name.
AT&T contended the FCC's 2005 decision did not obligate it to lease any lines to linkLine and that the arrangement shielded AT&T from antitrust claims. After legal wrangling on the district court level, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled the case could proceed. With the support of the Department of Justice, AT&T appealed the case to the Supreme Court.
"Defendants [AT&T] adopted procedures carefully calculated to deny ISPs access to an essential facility and to preserve and maintain its monopoly control of DSL access to the Internet," the Ninth Circuit ruled.
In accepting the case to be heard this fall, the Supreme Court said it would consider whether a "vertically integrated retail competitor with an alleged monopoly at a wholesale level but no antitrust duty to provide the wholesale input" could engage in price squeezing by leaving "insufficient margin between wholesale and retail prices to allow the plaintiff to compete."
According to the Ninth Circuit, a price squeeze occurs when a vertically integrated company sets its upstream prices or rates so high other companies are unable to compete.
|
|
x}kS㸶j&sнc t @va S*Jm:=w7$Ixt3Lw%/IK륥$3G3L{DcjQ=qOuޛ&6R(-GgP+N-w5 E]0ezNv@\ }@^cFD%x_'Щ-ѩwɘqPWɈ^ߖ͉6}^~d.pѲ
QmxyO`fzN<)_ER{B@T4IXߢðб7R=2p6B
x
X^P~D;5~A5~zЀ`V黖6# AUVekV]lv i!rs!gsͻHjPrFNww#25ARC[
04ԘHeCcW`Ww,ǃɩT*sTjQ3CmbZ35k-3ؾQt̀A3E5_C?)$fk8QʉwW<{e6)L|@AuӱaGeO5#o8ShewynJ
bT-v╇ioq3x[~*
e0>
?4p;Xrr]U9M3i^`dm-1}"@DeR)'I"0i6tt4[NBn$>8GFI/j/jy#Բ[-u_-\jzZzO``%
pbQ.Au;M-^m^:FX&R*CA-t!㽩S=>}m_unsEZ7VI3a
OɷV~k
pO{:$>~Xz>540V+JJ#OGY$Y-Qz;?# I,F[!fT}N}$y3DDȽ g/3/r.i } th8yWҽTVws
[t48;N.EsLVd];5y֏FZ*;{8n5{W#ҽ\t;6OZxXaZ`N). 8C]7je76R~ ^,*WL@F̶-a[ e u5qL>:NPm 5>l;4d}t>(>hhƋMriMrӇ{u4Aξ
w|h.x: }
00'w9uLP"iAЂMx>t Tَ]6}l29<8({hk=`DKwK@b!(բ!TgЦ,Z z]
X./lm^3-m`Z`1 5:%Kmr)Fa"9>] CRR,H6#hI#r
B,`@n!` Pw;.Vʥ\.3=ry !3grKvn ˥=*%nqR%a 3ʬ$&vϺ/[LboD6],Sm,gZ
X+%ڼ
fTWJ
>Ӥ75 Kܺye&,@H%\EwTGtt?\
n;At랒:\VM+}t>xFvOW#
ݜ6,Ǧ>&͵B3{BM\naDP$7:ϧHږiM- /2߄^W)9vC\D ry͚X 4ؐ|ƓB_n5zS\O΄ō$ ЊO}lYUo),~+%fsP.:R J#~7 Bɶ/^¼xeP4VR(k%2=2P,
CxEn҆}}Ssm_*_M}d27aZPK; ʸAS FjH [
҆tpku:.`Cϱ9麞`۱0]|O6* t>Je;~#
S5,6FԔfJ- _%t7s:P[%5f/{gqkq]ؑ.RL||j P[aHz>aTfla84-lO<wlļRF_vAiTWʅĨ%Q? {2,exY5mIr'j334]}ZJ4 89W!Po9> U4 ġMDb0raغ/k2qŝa&?@&R)Ö1g`iFlj,*IHRP$h!E5 dj>G8o#<Ѐ!ak"A.4bV6\,0|"j*VH0pl@:RԒxZC@^~zJ%$m4X2H]O=tvǜ}h3ʋ2i'z,R֊Z5Ɔ86Ԋ%Z~W@yOo燼 M]p/Qk>꿼;v?ogsaOo)Z`3TxKm`xujv0fdAc>eLJjAB;<wr
y-0&yRi@7G`+c%rȃ4t]3@$zd]
tB
HQVwAq9'&b)FGtlȂt !
2h:,`sY0 >AG5"h!(3E6(9
#!vV ;jZSR+b::>JKӥ ,GݮCfu>L:k}Y\W
ZQa/i+^> ) 50Ȁ%|=Gl1۩x]܁c2P=H(T\g7eME]ac6U{zn&)ZGڽϛvhTJ婛>7=or<-rF酛LK30j(Y+|` rfVɭ66霎0M,'\Qrb_,09E|փuKl?`L'k`p1\APBwlhԕ~5_r66~&zi1bw)n<0{L3gB>ִ
in`$dmPPww݊
Zk}@dCRk3-|o'U@&wrR)Y$
{259p\SemiG}A-a,0t&\☺砊Iy>2N*,E%b
()OUKj{[/0ւBMAh|?tt<͠1p
FU4z1HҧrSO(nURXUʅ
\t*9
^
LKfb;?ͅZ57eX~sB5xA%erIMq{a/;nK-%.@^ذ:Zk.SnIoΚ+Zx\Z3XҌh;|X^5eP$fP~'+jmW@ש5I-֊R{̡2b{#і$}7\DI'sSss]`A|7-kF#S$NR%*m\ܒNcĵ) JR!GYdI.|akJZܭ],g(
,O$(e,t=ǣۻmpI3Tg!,q'7gs5_v^sGDм>9Ey Z%<jԾ8jGV-N:GRygi÷[Te LR(>I16`d+]=-ao/GG銿F>;k["$r:y}!}9\x}ђ:'s9B DHͳKrBë=gUxi)qm2YG42ew\8$]wD8 uŀ@
c\8`\4c5IgAEW7fVl-yy_aZ XHy`|C(Wktσ}Ba_ HT
dQ{yNαgfOdZC@np Kz!N)0BG_XJI!)$j'e*K<;jv(6/ FWE'[+u{-$2}mC=]/8
݃͟*VRǭ7sCHY
>8/g`>IB8837 yKP .MunZW@{dl#J M5"v=Ok?qu#1a
1{|Iɰu͒:po<5s2)!MO|L+'IZV6X(UT%!T4QҌObCYB*C'ҽl^pVPto&_xvId%1hdgKE
3
KQka,TH>`)-#*VjRZ-.*$; 381
NAWO$^7QP]9Yz$ACvopBΛ>[|O0w+nt>Ninmơ8-J}~l+It2DySe{wȊ̙S.r!FtZx@2M3}:JfzӼ0iApjlOC\~d^}@<a
]ek;*);w}omVZtCqD!&x/.%Wg<E:'%:#Z/٦;ۈo-+Y\hdQ;WɎg
!OO=re.}Xs?4hg@[˱=Ιx
<v8\.߬k] B;BJ[42 UCn Uk=Ǭ§
,'iƿ'ʫqZԱQo*o_Oߛe{mA|=5e\1kp௩7/ז߂_B!CsѴg=.00yS/sK[⹍^mlQߎoo%v2;-3X#o#͒2`Lٙ"w;ʅԝzt&y&"عao}!5"^nlT[O>D~}fdLAC#|ns~xE F\R'JiR] </BU˲H(&|<8# H̞!c& ^(NNCGTXL⽽,n$EA{İ@KQE'jV>UPC(I-е+6A*hEXɠSI9 ,3橿f,` Ry.Bl0u@JRu̙0eu|)Qx^RmV*$ A lfA!?>ƣU^SԔ^Ou1:.F/uݩ'/Gim.!976FRQ?F7ץKQ9a!!B_IxP7m7cuċfĎ&eixh<
鮠JtWy)8M!EuLsd XDb_UA~t $t'<"RCՋ)Dx믩o/EaA7ҥi 3pR1y-Un֒9+ˌ !Λ=CmW R]\j/E.(Ro
:GM{KgT
4%zBa*3s2p2H#1ccJ=dQ0B<
!'%VB,UN;V|+\">Z5kA_R^M0PM:f؍ELzstν{/p5ꄰt5IX-MUa4g;5FTB(L`x0*}N[6F"\_QvsjT<BLy)TuR0y(9= Ovȭ)hI8=(5byi<5 kMuk4V<$"=})hlAI-WPG8pgC<a-B3x&5 ؕbzMzW@%7 V Zi%&vhpS !ܔ¬^:d0)B=UBXJlۘ
[rfJ"y:e0#*&00IË8?-D͙7$ʫyy%%P/tM36" xe;e7-mA8Ls8A[5瞀㠱+kLw0=GB6[[Jcdν)B&1^MCz;R3'z6E /I?W84QnX9czcy5@YjXxA,з}"0g |YO"oU<B̽/jٽ-O_:'lj]'4+xl m]u7G̣J A}5Ǿ9z^u:^xxYb[3*9CnAxD_:a|1d զ|I]sdVO+*nbs.KΓC^]Լ=\ӆm_ͶbCd0!wdBRg w_ߡf#Y/}(0K ]fPN\>Ox
i,-|XgK@؛~a7H ИSG@ػZ ^&78(Zt6֨pG b :m1\7,ގ.ł!901C , 1~34,dDB}76|}K26A2X\!q6#SN͒.@ZZň.g.pF" L0mVx&v#x"QUQq1ˢ6̲tn`&whzwKք@b(Cawh@ፖ YOFGd~l2&Wz's9zAL8+0r%jĴ.=)fg Ѱ+yAǫ7wL?p7{ hŗqE]yؿMXA2kA(/B-`B$;2cڌO%%~?뾠c+uU-1,ψ$Os]@VE]6, XagD)c穏{۱@-
@ȼ#M ԬD5:"UHJE`c?ℱfni?%S_WO4PWy{ɻƃ_8ٞm\;'; E
@}{.HԵ.jgy5_'ɻ>Dbd=5D?\<>C ۘL 6^Θh}~tרw=uLR0.eãEZNaG ,
xWq})^HE;{U5Ɨ q;ޛ'{->2?^*}"Qm?qT&ݤ>eW+|?^i
Y?6 O0q_יnyK9q#+;ga)('s:^[aZSPI\y
" I~`|x+>/bœ~/D㖸|J/V
z]kJ9-i/oQ*~ۘ̇1W&-8I
YW ~`E`YqG,T,=1;(6
T95䄲CO]YLa
CZ(M#&-%1V{#ߍ |