Apple Granted Permanent Injunction Against Psystar
Apple wins another round in litigation with clone computer maker Psystar as a judge grants Apple a permanent injunction against the company.The US District Court for the Northern District of California granted computer maker Apple a permanent injunction against Psystar Corporation, a Florida-based firm that had been selling clone PCs running Apple's Leopard and Snow Leopard operating systems. Judge William Aslup wrote allowing Psystar to continue would "irreparably harm the competitive position and market share" of Mac OS X, noting Apple's marketing campaign for the operating system "centers around promises of quality and customer support" that Psystar does not provide to its customers
In its motion for summary judgment filed in July 2008, Apple contended that Psystar's reproduction, modification, and distribution of Mac OS X on non-Apple computers constituted direct and contributory copyright infringement under the Copyright Act, and multiple violations of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). Psystar also moved for summary judgment on a number of affirmative defenses. In November, Apple won a copyright infringement claim against Psystar; Aslup rejected the basis of Psystar's countersuit, that Apple was misusing its copyright claims.
Apple claimed Psystar violated three of its exclusive rights in Mac OS X: its reproduction right, its distribution right and its right to create derivative works. In November 2008, Psystar's countersuit, claiming monopolistic practices and copyright misuse, was dismissed. However, in December of 2008 Psystar charged Apple was prohibited from bringing action against Psystar due to a failure to register certain copyrights, and claimed their actions did not amount to creating a derivative work because of modifications made to the source code and kernel extensions. Earlier this month, Psystar agreed to pay Apple $2.7 million in damages and legal fees to partially settle a dispute over the sale of such computers.