T-Mobile Claims Verizons Calculations Are Pointless

By Michelle Maisto  |  Posted 2012-04-05 Print this article Print


Fourth and most importantly, Shakey adds, Verizon glosses over the fact that spectrum in frequency bands below 1GHz is far more efficient than those above it. All of T-Mobile€™s spectrum is above 1GHz, while the majority of Verizon€™s is below it.

€œAn analysis that takes these factors into account,€ writes Sharkey, €œreveals that T-Mobile is actually more efficient than Verizon is in all five of the top markets, eight of the top 10 markets, and 31 of the top 49 markets, and that, on average, T-Mobile is 50 percent more efficient than Verizon in the top markets.€

As for Verizon€™s tendency to hoard, Sharkey writes that after the 2006 FCC AWS auction, Verizon let spectrum sit idle for €œfive and a half years and counting,€ and that it admits to sitting on capacity even while it looks to acquire more.

€œIndeed, Verizon€™s chief financial officer recently noted that that only 5 percent of its customer base is using its new LTE [Long-Term Evolution] network at 700MHz,€ he added.

Why should Verizon be allowed to acquire what it already has when others are in more desperate need? It shouldn€™t, says Sharkey.

By denying Verizon€™s spectrum deal with the cable companies, Sharkey explains, "the FCC would advance its pro-competitive goals for the wireless industry and create an environment in which the licenses could be made available to others who can put them to work immediately for the benefit of customers.€

Since Verizon and the cable companies first announced the deal in December 2011, the group has come under scrutiny from a number of sources and for a number of reasons. U.S. Sen. Al Franken (D-Minn.), has been vocal about his fears that the marketing details of the arrangement€”in which Comcast would bundle Verizon products with its own, for example€”would turn rival companies into partners.

€œI fear this will ultimately mean less competition, less choice and higher prices for consumers,€ Franken wrote in a Jan. 31 letter to FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski.

A number of organizations have come out in favor of the deal, in as much as it would make idle spectrum available to consumers€”an assumption that Sharkey and T-Mobile suggest shouldn€™t be made.

Announcing the deal in December, Verizon CEO Dan Mead said in a statement, "Americans deserve excellence from a wireless service provider, and innovative wireless companies plan ahead in order to deliver on that expectation. Spectrum is the raw material on which wireless networks are built, and buying the AWS spectrum now solidifies our network leadership into the future, and will enable us to bring even better 4G LTE products and services to our customers."

Before a Senate Subcommittee hearing March 22, Randall Milch, Verizon executive vice president and general counsel, testified that the bundles would be optional for customers and offer nothing other than €œconvenience or a discount of sorts that the consumer can choose or not choose.€


Michelle Maisto has been covering the enterprise mobility space for a decade, beginning with Knowledge Management, Field Force Automation and eCRM, and most recently as the editor-in-chief of Mobile Enterprise magazine. She earned an MFA in nonfiction writing from Columbia University, and in her spare time obsesses about food. Her first book, The Gastronomy of Marriage, if forthcoming from Random House in September 2009.

Submit a Comment

Loading Comments...
Manage your Newsletters: Login   Register My Newsletters

Rocket Fuel