Just Say No to AT&T-BellSouth

By David Morgenstern  |  Posted 2006-03-20 Print this article Print

Opinion: The Bell System was dismantled in 1984. Its gradual reassembly bodes ill for enterprises and consumers alike.

The news that AT&T would purchase BellSouth for $67.1 billion triggered a flashback. In 1984, the government dismantled the Bell System, breaking it up into a pack of operating companies. A generation later, the pieces seem to be reassembling themselves.

But todays telecommunications landscape is vastly different from that of 1984. Theres an established market for cellular communications that didnt exist then, and consumers and businesses alike require broadband for Internet services, including voice and video over IP.

According to AT&Ts calculations, the cost savings are expected to top $2 billion two years after the deal closes and eventually total about $18 billion as a result of layoffs, lower advertising expenses and lower operating costs. Analysts expect the merger to sail through the antitrust and Federal Communications Commission regulatory reviews.

Were not convinced. This deal should sound the alarm for small and midsize businesses and even large ones. Will we really be better off with just two telecom players: AT&T and Verizon? We dont think so. A duopoly is not the robust field of competitors envisioned by Judge Harold Green in his 1984 breakup of the Bell System. Federal regulators must demand clear proof the merger wont diminish competition and, therefore, reduce choices and keep rates high.

Click here to read more about the affect this acquisition could have on SMBs. At the time of the breakup, the needs of enterprise customers were important to AT&T. Today, consumers rule. Advances in wireless, mobile applications, rich content delivery, and voice and video over IP are all driven by the demands of consumers. The narrowing of competition just makes it that much more likely that enterprise concerns will take a back seat or, worse, be ignored.

Its likely that new technologies will find it difficult to penetrate a market dominated by an unregulated duopoly. It may not be possible to stop innovation, but its certainly possible to slow it. The deal will make it all too easy for the best technology to be squashed or for the wrong technology to be blessed.

Perhaps most ominously, the future of Internet neutrality could be imperiled. The pressure is already on to divvy up Internet bandwidth and make further progress dependent on toll fees. What position will AT&T take on the issue? With only two big players in the market and the barrier to new entrants insurmountable, it will be easier to push the notion of auctioning quality Internet service to the highest bidder.

To read more about Net neutrality, click here. Sooner or later our government must take a stand. First, the benefits of competition must be fought for—and that includes having the courage to stand up to powerful lobbying interests that benefit from consolidation. Second, Net neutrality must be upheld. Enterprise telecom customers deserve to have a wide choice of quality providers. They wont be getting that with only two players in the market. The FCC and Department of Justice should block this merger.

Tell us what you think at eWEEK@ziffdavis.com.

For reader response to this column, click here. Check out eWEEK.coms for the latest news, views and analysis on voice over IP and telephony.
David Morgenstern is Executive Editor/Special Projects of eWEEK. Previously, he served as the news editor of Ziff Davis Internet and editor for Ziff Davis' Storage Supersite.

In 'the days,' he was an award-winning editor with the heralded MacWEEK newsweekly as well as eMediaweekly, a trade publication for managers of professional digital content creation.

David has also worked on the vendor side of the industry, including companies offering professional displays and color-calibration technology, and Internet video.

He can be reached here.


Submit a Comment

Loading Comments...
Manage your Newsletters: Login   Register My Newsletters

Rocket Fuel