Twitter CEO Dick Costolo at Mobile World Congress moved to put to bed the notion that the microblog service would sell to Google or Facebook. Still, the rumors persist.
Twitter CEO Dick Costolo dismissed as
rumors reports that Google and Facebook have offered to purchase the microblog
service, the latest in an acquisition story with a long tail.
The Wall Street Journal rekindled
the rumor when it said Google and Facebook held
low-level talks with Twitter about buying the company for $8 billion to $10
Costolo, speaking at Mobile World Congress in Barcelona,
Spain, Feb. 14, said,
"I don't know where these things come from. It's just a rumor."
Costolo, who took the helm
as CEO from
co-founder Evan Williams in October, has frequently downplayed acquisition
talks, noting that Twitter's goal is to remain independent and grow a large
The company in December banked $200 million funding that valued the company
at $3.7 billion. To wit, an $8 billion or
$10 billion offer appears handsome.
Still, in a world where money talks, not every company is like Twitter or
Groupon, which thumbed its nose at a $6 billion tender offer from Google last
It's easy to see why Google and Facebook, whose rivalry has intensified as
the social network has lured eyeballs from the search giant, would be interested
Twitter has 200 million users, accounting for 130 million tweets per day.
According to eMarketer, Twitter is on pace to make
$150 million in advertising, or triple its 2010
earnings, in 2011. The upside is great.
One interesting question is which company Twitter would best fit: Facebook
or Google? Facebook, one could argue, already has the communication tools,
including status updates and chat, that might make Twitter unnecessary.
Yet Forrester Research analyst Augie Ray sees Twitter as being quite
attractive to the social network's designs because Twitter's trove of data
about people and their interests would well fit Facebook's business model.
"What is less clear to me is the benefit Twitter would receive, outside
of cash of course, for merging with Facebook," Ray told eWEEK. "Given
their commitment to their product and vision, one of the concerns those at
Twitter may have about Facebook may be the autonomy they'd be allowed and how
Facebook envisions integrating Twitter into the Facebook experience."
Ray said an acquisition by Google might make more sense for Twitter given
Google's self-service platform for ad purchasing. Twitter is currently
developing its own self-service platform for its Promoted ad products.
There is a Catch-22 with the Google-Twitter tie. Google has lagged in social
software, which makes Twitter more desirable for the search engine.
However, Twitter executives know full well the risks of joining Google after
the Web giant let the early social location service Dodgeball languish before
founder Dennis Crowley left to form the highly successful Foursquare.
In any case, if Twitter is firm in its resolve to stay independent, the
story is a nonissue. But if it is wavering in its resolve, at least it appears
to have exit options.
"Twitter must make some decisions as to how quickly they can scale, the
risks they may encounter, and the benefits that could come from combining with
another organization and getting access to their technology and user
base," Ray said. "It can be hard for a company that has just $100 to
$150 million of revenue [reportedly] to turn down an offer of $8 billion."