Why Facebook's Free Basics Internet Service Stirs Up Controversy

 
 
By Don Reisinger  |  Posted 2016-02-17 Print this article Print
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
  • Previous
    Why Facebook's Free Basics Internet Service Stirs Up Controversy
    Next

    Why Facebook's Free Basics Internet Service Stirs Up Controversy

    Facebook, through its Free Basics platform, hopes to bring the Internet to people in emerging markets. But not all countries are on board. Here's why.
  • Previous
    Free Basics Is Facebook's Brain Child
    Next

    Free Basics Is Facebook's Brain Child

    Although Facebook isn't the only company involved in Free Basics, it's getting the most attention because the social media giant kicked off the Internet.org initiative. Facebook is the program's leading backer and doing more than any other firm to expand it globally. Without Facebook, there would be no Free Basics.
  • Previous
    Facebook Is Working With Partners
    Next

    Facebook Is Working With Partners

    Facebook is working with partners in an effort to expand Internet access around the world. Samsung, Qualcomm, Ericsson and a few other firms are involved in getting free Internet to those who don't have connectivity. Facebook also partners with local mobile operators in individual countries.
  • Previous
    Facebook Is Focusing on Emerging Markets
    Next

    Facebook Is Focusing on Emerging Markets

    Central to the Free Basics mission is to provide free Internet access to people in emerging markets. As of this writing, Free Basics is available in 38 countries, including Angola, Ghana, Kenya and even Iraq. Facebook says it will expand Free Basics to more countries, in hopes of getting billions of people connected to the Internet.
  • Previous
    Facebook Is the Ultimate Gatekeeper
    Next

    Facebook Is the Ultimate Gatekeeper

    Because Free Basics is essentially Facebook's idea, the social network holds the keys to the kingdom. For a while, Facebook only allowed certain services onto its platform, limiting where users could go. Finally, Facebook opened up Free Basics to any Website, but has placed restrictions on the amount of data that can be used, content that can be distributed and more. In other words, any company can join Free Basics and get its platform in front of users, but first, it will have to be vetted by Facebook.
  • Previous
    The Question Over Net Neutrality
    Next

    The Question Over Net Neutrality

    The ultimate question, therefore, is whether Free Basics violates net neutrality, or the idea that the Internet should be open and free to any and all participants. India ultimately decided that Free Basics violated net neutrality by essentially creating a "walled garden" in which Facebook would control who could get in. Facebook, a longtime net neutrality supporter, has argued that some Internet is better than no Internet and it in no way sees Free Basics as a violation of net neutrality.
  • Previous
    Facebook Wants to Be the Web Portal to Emerging Markets
    Next

    Facebook Wants to Be the Web Portal to Emerging Markets

    By placing itself at the center of the Free Basics platform, Facebook has created a scenario in which it's the portal for potentially billions of people to see the Internet. Free Basics is designed for those who have never been online and don't necessarily know about companies like Google, Microsoft or Amazon. By offering Free Basics, Facebook wants to get a chance to introduce billions of additional potential users to its social network and related services. That could ultimately help the company's user numbers grow substantially in the coming years.
  • Previous
    This Is Why Zuckerberg Is Offering Free Basics
    Next

    This Is Why Zuckerberg Is Offering Free Basics

    So, why is Mark Zuckerberg offering Free Basics? In a town hall meeting in India last year, he was clear that he believed it was in the best interests of disadvantaged people who would otherwise lose out in the information economy. In an op-ed published in the last few days before Indian regulators pulled the plug on Free Basics, Zuckerberg made one last plea, pointing to farmers that benefited from Free Basics. He also argued that while Free Basics wouldn't be the ultimate solution for Internet connectivity, it was a step in the right direction. "Who could possibly be against this?" he asked in the op-ed.
  • Previous
    Critics Decry Facebook's Control Over Free Basics
    Next

    Critics Decry Facebook's Control Over Free Basics

    On the same day that Zuckerberg's op-ed was published in The Times of India, a "counterview" op-ed was published by Indian entrepreneur Nikhil Pahwa. He argued that Free Basics violates net neutrality by choosing its partners and deciding for itself what companies get access to its users. He argued that Facebook was "rejecting the option of giving the poor free access to the open, plural, and diverse web." He also decried Zuckerberg's claim that being able to access some of the Internet is better than none of it. His comments echoed those made by other critics, who have charged Facebook with having too much control and putting itself in a position to eventually benefit financially.
  • Previous
    Free Basics Tries to Reduce the Cost of Data Downloads
    Next

    Free Basics Tries to Reduce the Cost of Data Downloads

    To understand Free Basics, one must understand how emerging markets work. Approximately 85 percent of the world is covered through mobile networks. However, downloading data over those networks can be exceedingly expensive in developing countries. Facebook's idea is to partner with local carriers that will swallow the cost. Meanwhile, Facebook and its partners work to limit how much data is consumed by apps to reduce the burden on carriers. Ultimately, the goal is to get users to move to a paid subscription so they can have full Internet access.
  • Previous
    Free Basics' Uncertain Future
    Next

    Free Basics' Uncertain Future

    So, what's next for Free Basics? At least right now, opinions are split. There are some—especially those in the Facebook camp—who believe the ban in India is little more than a bump in the road. They argue that Free Basics will expand over time and more people will get online. Others, however, say that India may have set an example and woken up countries about the potential impact Free Basics will have on their own citizens and might prompt them to follow India's lead.
 

Who knew free Internet access could become an international political issue? In the past several days, Facebook's Free Basics platform has come under fire after authorities in India banned it, calling it a violation of network neutrality rules. The news was the culmination of months of fighting between Facebook and Indian regulators over whether Free Basics should be available to Indian users. Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg, who spearheads the effort, argued that Free Basics provides an opportunity for the disadvantaged to succeed in an increasingly competitive world. India, however, ultimately decided that it gave Facebook too much power and limited free and open access to the Internet. The debate is ongoing, but it's an issue that could have huge ramifications on people in emerging markets around the world. This slide show discusses what Free Basics is all about, how it works and why it will likely spark controversy in developing countries years to come as the two sides clash over what's best for people who have never been on the Internet.

 
 
 
 
 
Don Reisinger is a freelance technology columnist. He started writing about technology for Ziff-Davis' Gearlog.com. Since then, he has written extremely popular columns for CNET.com, Computerworld, InformationWeek, and others. He has appeared numerous times on national television to share his expertise with viewers. You can follow his every move at http://twitter.com/donreisinger.
 
 
 
 
 
 

Submit a Comment

Loading Comments...
 
Manage your Newsletters: Login   Register My Newsletters























 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Rocket Fuel