Oracle 9iAS Struggles to Keep Up With Hype

 
 
By John Taschek  |  Posted 2001-12-17
 
 
 

If Real Application Clusters isnt the breakthrough database technology that Larry Ellison said it is, hes going to take up sailing full time.

Ellison may well be sailing more next year, when the Ellison-sponsored Oracle racing team vies for the Americas Cup. Interestingly, the focus of Oracle OpenWorld earlier this month was not on RAC or databases at all, but on Release 2 of Oracles application server—9iAS. With the announcement of the app server, Oracles gung-ho leader—the last interesting character in the software world—roasted his two closest rivals, BEA and IBM.

Its highly entertaining stuff, but Im never sure the full story is being told. Take Oracles major claims:

Oracle lags behind BEA and IBM because its new in the market. Not quite. Oracles been in the app server market for years. Perhaps Ellison means that Oracles new to the J2EE market, or maybe just the "working" application server market.

Oracles app server is far faster than BEAs WebLogic and IBMs WebSphere. In some recent tests, it appears that Oracle 9iAS is indeed faster than WebSphere, but a closer look shows that it was tested against an old version of WebSphere. New numbers are due in February—Id wait for those.

Oracles application development platform is more integrated than BEAs and IBMs. Its more integrated because there are fewer things to integrate. It doesnt have many of the capabilities that other app servers have, such as full heterogeneous transaction support across a multitude of systems.

Oracles growth exceeds that of BEA and IBM. I sure hope so. Oracles coming from a place so low on the totem pole that 100 percent growth doesnt amount to all that much. Its a good start, but we have to make sure Oracle isnt counting those giveaway app servers.

Oracles application server costs less than BEAs or IBMs. Who knows? It might be free for the big customers. Is it because you get less? IBM, at least, is having none of the cost claims. "An act of desperation," several IBM officials said. "Its an interesting way to generate news."

Thats where I come in. Oracle 9iAS looks like great technology if you can get past the marketing campaign.

Who is using 9iAS? I want to hear from you. Write to me at john_taschek@ziffdavis.com.

Rocket Fuel