Moving on Up to Network-Based Protection

By Larry Seltzer  |  Posted 2003-03-17

Moving on Up to Network-Based Protection

If you have a small network for your home or business it probably grew up from some small number of disconnected systems. You may have—and should have—security measures implemented at each client system and, I would hope, at any servers.

But once you have a network connected to the Internet, its important to consider network-based protections. This gives you protection in case a weakness emerges on any one of the internal computers. It probably also provides protection from two different vendors, which makes it even more likely to catch rare problems that would slip through one of them. Finally, network protection gives you an element of control over your users in case you dont completely trust them.

There are two important classes of products in this regard: firewalls and antivirus protection. Actual network firewalls and network devices claiming to be firewalls are relatively common, but unfortunately network-based antivirus is still a fairly high-end product.

If you have a broadband router from a company such as D-Link or Linksys, you may have the impression that its also a firewall, but it probably isnt. These devices all provide NAT (Network Address Translation), which means that the router uses your real IP address that you got from your ISP when communicating with the rest of the Internet. Internally your computers all get fake IP addresses (probably in the 192.168.x.x range) that dont actually route out to the Internet. The fact that computers on the outside cant directly address your computers does provide some measure of protection, but its an exaggeration to call this a "firewall."

Hardware appliances that do have true firewall functionality are more expensive and more complicated to administer, but they do present a much more difficult barrier to an attacker. A talented and determined attacker will be able to penetrate the average NAT router. A true firewall performs a task called "stateful inspection," where it actually examines the packets of data moving in and out of the network, looking for evidence of attacks. For instance, if a firewall sees ICMP packets, it can look for the famous "PING Of Death" attack, which involves an oversize buffer.

More On Network

-Based Protection">

More On Network-Based Protection

On my own network I use Ositis Softwares Winproxy 5. Its the only affordable product I know of that provides both network-based firewall and network-based antivirus. The annual antivirus definition subscriptions are also very reasonably priced—about $10 per client per year, depending on how many you buy. Im not entirely happy with Winproxy, and perhaps its biggest weakness is that they do not support VPN connections from the Internet into the local network. Plus, it requires a computer to run on, and appliances are so much simpler and cheaper.

Its tempting, once you have network-based protection, to think that client-based protection is a waste. In one sense, it really is a "belt-and-suspenders" thing, but I know from personal experience that its worthwhile. Over the years Ive had relatively few virues get through the Trend antivirus scanner in my Winproxy box, but a few have, and they have all been blocked by the Norton antivirus at my clients. Theres no doubt in my mind that its a very good idea to have network-based antivirus, and its essential to have client-based antivirus. And if you follow this strategy, make sure to get the two products from different vendors.

In all honesty, I cant say the same about firewalls. If you have a network-based firewall, theres a good argument to have client-side firewalls, too, but its a harder case to make. The scenario that youd want to watch for would be if some sort of Trojan Horse snuck through the antivirus protection and ran on one of the clients, attacking other clients inside the network. If it communicated outside to the Internet it would have to get past the network firewall.

Most of these products are not designed for consumers, so you may need more expertise than you expected. In fact, especially for a business, you should probably get a consultant to help. If somethings worth doing, its worth doing right.

Security Supersite Editor Larry Seltzer has worked in and written about the computer industry since 1983.

Rocket Fuel