HP Planning ARM-Based Servers With Calxeda, Challenging Intel: Reports
Hewlett-Packard reportedly will partner with chip-maker Calxeda to develop data center servers powered by low-power processors designed by ARM Holdings.
Quoting unnamed people close to the situation, Bloomberg and the Wall Street Journal are reporting that HP will become the first major OEM to adopt ARM-based processors for some of its servers, a move that would heighten the growing competition between ARM and Intel, the world's top chip maker.
Intel, which holds more than 80 percent of the overall global chip market and 90 percent of the $9 billion worldwide server chip space, has been aggressive in trying to break into the mobile device space, particularly smartphones and tablets, the bulk of which currently are powered by ARM chips manufactured by the likes of Texas Instruments, Samsung, Qualcomm and Nvidia.
At the same time, ARM executives have been vocal about their plans to move up the ladder and into PCs and low-power servers, and a number of manufacturers-including Calxeda, Marvell Technologies and Nvidia-are developing chips for the data center. Calxeda has a product-based event scheduled for Nov. 1, though the company has not yet said what the event will be about.
A Calxeda spokesperson declined to comment on the HP reports.
ARM CEO Warren East late last year said he expected to begin chipping away at Intel's server dominance in 2014, a sentiment echoed in recent interviews by ARM Vice President Michael Inglis. ARM executives argue that enterprises-particularly those with large and dense data centers-will gravitate toward more energy-efficient solutions, a strength of ARM's designs. ARM last year unveiled the Cortex-A15 design, which offers features that are important in servers, including greater memory capacity and virtualization support.
Intel continues to see strong growth in its Data Center Group, reporting Oct. 18 that third-quarter revenue for the unit hit $2.5 billion, a jump of 15 percent over the same period in 2010. HP is its largest customer.
Data center power and cooling costs have become key concerns for enterprises, with the cost of running a system surpassing the cost of buying one. That is particularly acute in dense, hyperscale environments-like those at such places as Facebook and Google-where large numbers of small servers are running staggering amounts of tasks. Officials from ARM and its partners say it is these smaller, Web-based transactions that represent the best opportunity to gain a foothold in data centers, where power efficiency is even more important than pure performance.
That's important, given that x86 processors from Intel and Advanced Micro Devices offer greater performance than ARM processors, though they consume more power. However, software is another obstacle facing ARM-based chips. Most data center software is designed to run on the x86 instruction set; moving applications to another instruction set would be difficult and expensive.
A move to offer ARM-based servers could be a boon to HP, according to Brian Marshall, an analyst with International Strategy and Investment Group. In a note Oct. 26, Marshall estimated that HP could save about $200 per ARM-based server. Assuming that HP uses ARM-based chips in 30 percent of its industry-standard servers, the move could boost the company's operating margin and add about $220 million in operating income in 2012, he said.
It also could give HP leverage over competitors when trying to sell servers into data centers where power consumption is a key factor, Marshall said.
HP isn't the only top-tier server OEM to consider ARM-based chips. Forrest Norrod, vice president and general manager of Dell's Data Center Solutions unit, told eWEEK in an interview this summer that his company is keeping an eye on developments, and usually has test systems powered by non-x86 chips running in its labs. Dell is aware of the demands from businesses for more energy-efficient technologies and wants to ensure it has the products to meet those demands, Norrod said.
However, the window of opportunity may be closing a bit for ARM-based chip manufacturers to gain significant traction in the data center, he said. A year ago, Norrod believed ARM's presence in the data center was almost a certainty. However, the move is taking longer than he expected, particularly in the area of software support.
"The ecosystem is not quite there yet," Norrod said. "But it's not insurmountable."
At the same time, Intel and AMD both are aggressively driving up the energy efficiency of their server chips.
"How long will it be before Intel and AMD close the power and density gap so that [ARM-based chips are] no longer intriguing enough" for businesses to make the change, Norrod said. "I've seen a lot of aggressive roadmap acceleration [from Intel and AMD] and a lot of attention to power and density."
Right now, it's difficult to determine whether ARM will be able to make a significant move into the data center, or if the work Intel and AMD are doing with their chips will satisfy the data center demands from enterprises. "I think it's a coin flip," Norrod said.
The ARM-vs.-x86 competition also has the attention of Norrod's boss. During Dell's investors conference in June, CEO Michael Dell said ARM's efforts were a welcomed development in the market.
"I think that right now ARM chips can perform some basic tasks and they are going to get more and more powerful, and I think the x86 guys are going to fight back and fight back hard," Dell said.