Google Android as Open as Ever, Claims Rubin
Android creator Andy Rubin lashed out at media April 6 for suggesting that Google is increasingly putting the clamps in its open source mobile operating system, and promised the platform will continue to be open for modification.
Responding to a March 30 article from Bloomberg BusinessWeek that claimed Google is instilling tighter controls on Android and offering early deals for preferred partners, Rubin in a blog post described the allegations as "misinformation in the press about Android and Google's role in supporting the ecosystem."
The misinformation he is alluding to from the article is that Rubin himself has been demanding that Android licensees agree to "non-fragmentation clauses" that give Google the final say on how they can tweak the Android code and even with whom they may partner. The article's point is that Rubin is trying to curb fragmentation of an already fragmented platform.
Rubin said that such clauses have always been part of the Android license, but the article argued that Google has tightened up its policies for partners such as Facebook, Verizon and offered some sweetheart deals to others.
The Bloomberg BusinessWeek article's credibility was bolstered because it came one week after the same publication correctly reported that Google was delaying the open source release of its Android 3.0 "Honeycomb" code for tablets because it wasn't finished adapting the software to work on smartphones and other gadgets.
Rubin said device makers are free to modify Android to
customize any range of features for Android devices, but noted that those who
wish to market a device as Android-compatible or include Google apps on the
device, the company requires that device conform with "basic compatibility
Moreover, he said Google's "anti-fragmentation" program has been in place since Android's inception and remains a priority to provide a great user experience for consumers and a consistent platform for developers.
"Our approach remains unchanged: there are no lock-downs or restrictions against customizing UIs," Rubin wrote. "There are not, and never have been, any efforts to standardize the platform on any single chipset architecture."
Fragmentation is indeed still an issue. Google's own device dashboard shows 7 OS builds, 6 for smartphones and one for tablets. Baird found that 56 percent of Android developers are concerned about increasing fragmentation in the platform.
Rubin also acknowledged that his team is still working to bring all of the new Honeycomb features to phones and promised to publish the code when it is finished. "This temporary delay does not represent a change in strategy. We remain firmly committed to providing Android as an open source platform across many device types."
Rubin vowed that Google will continue to work toward an open and healthy ecosystem "because we truly believe this is best for the industry and best for consumers."
What Rubin didn't address is the allegations that Google releases code to preferred hardware makers and carriers for early access, giving those partners advantages in time to market.
TechCrunch suggested such sweetheart deals are indeed going on, though it does not provide evidence to the point.