Enterprise Mobility: LABS GALLERY: MyTouch 3G with Google and Touch Pro2 Bolster T-Mobile's Stable of Smartphones

 
 
By Andrew Garcia  |  Posted 2009-09-03
 
 
 

LABS GALLERY: MyTouch 3G with Google and Touch Pro2 Bolster T-Mobile's Stable of Smartphones

 

LABS GALLERY: MyTouch 3G with Google and Touch Pro2 Bolster T-Mobile's Stable of Smartphones

MyTouch 3G with Google

The MyTouch measures a compact 2.2 by 4.5 by 0.6 inches, and weighs 4.1 ounces. The device is available now from T-Mobile in Merlot (shown), black and white.

MyTouch 3G with Google

HTC Touch Pro2

By most metrics, the HTC Touch Pro2 is not actually much bigger than the MyTouch, although it seems like it. Measuring 2.4 by 4.6 by 0.7 inches, and weighing a very hefty 6.6 ounces, T-Mobile's Touch Pro2 is available only in mocha.

HTC Touch Pro2

Touch Pro2 Keyboard

The Touch Pro2 has an absolutely outstanding slide-out keyboard (and a tilt screen).

Touch Pro2 Keyboard

Touch Pro2 On-Screen Keyboard

With its resistive touch-screen and haptic feedback, the Touch Pro2 provides a clunky and unforgiving typing experience. Stick with the slide-out keyboard on this device.

Touch Pro2 On-Screen Keyboard

MyTouch: No Keyboard

Like the iPhone, the MyTouch 3G offers no physical keyboard, relying instead on an on-screen keyboard on the device's capacitive display. On the other hand, the MyTouch offers a handful of physical keys and a track ball for easier navigation.

MyTouch: No Keyboard

Android Keyboard

Leveraging the device's capacitive touch-screen, the MyTouch on-screen keyboard is responsive and fairly forgiving in either portrait or landscape mode.

Android Keyboard

MyTouch Back

On the back of the MyTouch is a 3.2-megapixel still and video camera, and a rather tinny-sounding speakerphone.

MyTouch Back

Touch Pro2 Back

The Touch Pro2 also has a 3.2-megapixel still and video camera, along with a mute button. Under certain circumstances, the speakerphone sound quality is outstanding, but if your hand covers the speakers even slightly, sound quality rapidly muffles or begins to rattle.

Touch Pro2 Back

Clean Lines

The edges of the MyTouch are barely marred by buttons or ports. On the side is a volume control. On the bottom is a single ExtUSB connector for power, data link or headset. To support 3.5-mm headsets, the MyTouch comes with an adapter (lower right).

Clean Lines

MyTouch Battery

The MyTouch 3G comes with a 1,340 mAh lithium-ion battery, rated for 7 hours of talk time or 16 days on standby with a GSM connection. Estimates are not provided in the literature for a 3G connection.

MyTouch Battery

Touch Pro2 Battery

The Touch Pro2 has a 1,500 mAh battery, rated for 6.5 hours of talk time or 31 days standby with a 3G connection. With a GSM connection, estimates bump up to about 8.5 hours of talk time or almost 21 days standby.

Touch Pro2 Battery

Home Screens

The home screens of the two devices show the different philosophies behind the different operating systems. At left, HTC's TouchFlo interface on the Touch Pro2 steers users to recent and forthcoming calls or appointments. On the right, Android on the MyTouch 3G makes it easy to search the Internet, right away.

Home Screens

Dialers

At left, the Touch Pro2 dialer relies on menus to access some, but not all, features. At right, the Android dialer is finger-friendly and well laid out.

Dialers

E-Mail Accounts

At left, the Touch Pro2 has one e-mail application for all e-mail accounts—whether IMAP, POP3 or ActiveSync/Outlook. At right, the MyTouch 3G has two—one for Gmail and one for POP3/IMAP (but again, no integrated ActiveSync support).

E-Mail Accounts

Android Wi-Fi

From the settings menu, MyTouch 3G users can easily attach to 802.11b/g Wi-Fi networks using standards-based encryption.

Android Wi-Fi

Wi-Fi Controls

Wi-Fi controls are a mess on the Touch Pro2. There are TouchFlo controls, and there are WinMo controls (lower left) that do the same thing. Somehow, I found one tool would disable the Wi-Fi radio as I tried to enable it in the other.

Wi-Fi Controls

Android Zoom

The built-in Web browser displays full Websites that can be hard to read at the default display size. On-screen zoom controls, finger manipulation of the view, on-screen search functions and a magnifier make it easier to find the content you want.

Android Zoom

Touch Pro2 Zoom

The default browser (Internet Explorer) uses sites' mobile editions by default, obviating an immediate need for zoom controls. For zoom controls, go to menu. The Touch Pro2 also comes preconfigured with Opera Mini.

Touch Pro2 Zoom

Rocket Fuel