IT Security & Network Security News & Reviews: Wiretapping the Internet: Inside Government Web Monitoring Efforts

 
 
By Brian Prince  |  Posted 2011-02-23
 
 
 

Wiretapping the Internet: Inside Government Web Monitoring Efforts

by Brian Prince

Wiretapping the Internet: Inside Government Web Monitoring Efforts

Going Dark

Going Dark is the FBIs name for law enforcement's inability to lawfully collect and analyze data and conduct electronic surveillance due to the rapid evolution of technology. The EFF (Electronic Frontier Foundation) recently unearthed documents detailing an FBI initiative to address the issue as part of a five-pronged strategy: Modernizing lawful intercept laws, updating lawful intercept authorities, increasing law enforcement coordination, establishing broader industry partnerships and seeking more funding for these efforts.

Going Dark

Legislation as an Answer

In comments Feb. 17, FBI General Counsel Valerie Caproni said the FBI did not have specific requests for legislation yet, noting that the topic is being debated by the Obama Administration. She also said the issue was less about the government having the legal authority to intercept communications and more about the practical challenges of intercepting communications investigators have been authorized to collect.

Legislation as an Answer

Wiretapping the Internet: Inside Government Web Monitoring Efforts - Page 4

Internal DebateWhile legislation is being debated, in September reports surfaced that indicated that discussions about addressing the issue were coalescing around three elements: Communications services that encrypt messages must be able to unscramble them; foreign-based providers doing business inside the United States must have a domestic office capable of performing intercepts; and developers of software using peer-to-peer communication must redesign their services to allow interception.

Wiretapping the Internet: Inside Government Web Monitoring Efforts - Page 4

Privacy and Security Concerns

The idea of expanding law enforcement powers has touched off concerns for a variety of reasons, a key one being that building backdoors in programs to allow government surveillance creates a situation that could be exploited by cyber-criminals as well.

Privacy and Security Concerns

Business Concerns

Another worry is that mandating that backdoors be inserted by programmers could hurt the competitiveness of many companies operating within the United States.

Business Concerns

Get Them to the Greek

In 2005, it was discovered that rogue software abused the legal intercept mechanism in Vodafones digital switches to spy on phones belonging to more than 100 people, including Greek politicians and civil rights figures. When the dust settled, the Communications Privacy Protection Authority fined Vodafone Greece more than $104 million in 2006.

Get Them to the Greek

The FBI's case for CALEA

CALEA (Communications Assistance for Law Enforcement Act), passed in 1994, requires telephone companies build their networks so they are capable of intercepting a users communications as soon as the company is given a wiretap order. Though the act has been interpreted to cover VOIP (voice over IP), it does not cover other Internet-based communication methods, such as Webmail or peer-to-peer services, according to Caproni.

The FBI's case for CALEA

Updating ECPA

The Electronic Communications Privacy Act of 1986 was designed to extend government restrictions on wire taps from telephone calls to include transmissions of electronic data by computer. Last year, privacy advocates and industry heavyweights, including Microsoft and Google, began pushing for an update to the law that balances user privacy with law enforcement needs and addresses discrepancies. For example, e-mails stored for fewer than 180 days receive greater privacy protections than e-mails stored for a longer period.

Updating ECPA

Wiretapping the Internet: Inside Government Web Monitoring Efforts - Page 10

 

Wiretapping the Internet: Inside Government Web Monitoring Efforts - Page 10

Rocket Fuel