Most of us once judged notebook computers using a certain set of criteria in a fairly standard order: comfort, cost, power and battery life. Now that costs are within expectations and power is generally adequate across the board, my entire judging criteria has been blown to bits. I suspect that the manufacturers want it this way. That way they market their notebooks to fit any occasion. The technical guts are there, of course, but new markets are created when style supersedes substance. Think Apple and polo shirts, for example.
For the manufacturers, however, there seems to be a little battle brewing. The reason: Transmeta has tossed a curveball into an industry that was hitting home runs off fastballs for at least a decade. Transmeta is banking on power consumption, cooling and size as the next big considerations in the industry. But it hasnt convinced all the manufacturers that power savings over power processing is the way to go. This is nuts. Its crazy to believe that anyone would not want a device with an 8-hour battery life vs. something that had 3.5 hours, even if the latter device was 20 percent faster. Thats the story I got from talking with the notebook and chip manufacturers. Motion Computing, for example, the new company formed by former Dell executives, said Transmetas Crusoe chip set was too slow. So did some other manufacturers, even though I had seen Crusoe-based prototypes from them. Transmeta-based devices probably are significantly slower than Intel-and AMD-based devices. The chip set requires an abstraction layer that translates x86 code (Windows) into Crusoe code. This is the stuff Linus Torvalds is working on.
Its possible, in some cases, that performance over battery life is essential. Motion, which is targeting the vertical markets with its Tablet PC design, probably made a correct choice. Motion also will become the Tablet PC research and pilot development arm for Dell (my speculation), so Intel chip sets are a good fit. In general, however, mobility depends on greater battery life. Couple this thought with the reigning principle of the computing industry—that value is added as density increases—and you have an excellent case for Transmetas designs, which allow for smaller form factors, including the OQO device (very cool) and some of those fashionable Sonys.
Whats more important in your line of work—battery or performance? Write to me at john_taschek@ziffdavis.com.