eWEEK content and product recommendations are editorially independent. We may make money when you click on links to our partners. Learn More.
Apples iWork 08 boasts improvements to the software suites word processing and presentation applications, but—more importantly—it fills the suites spreadsheet hole with Numbers.
eWEEK Labs ran Numbers through its paces, and found it to be a strong addition to the productivity software market and a promising alternative to Microsoft Excel.
The inclusion of Numbers certainly positions iWork to compete with the Microsoft Office suite, and replaces the now defunct AppleWorks suite. Emphasizing the spreadsheet programs ease of use, yet promising the ability to create sophisticated document, users can create and edit highly technical business documents as easily as they can create a simple family budget.
At the official launch of iWork 08, on Aug. 7, Apple CEO Steve Jobs emphasized Numbers ease of use and pointed to features, such as its intelligent tables, that allow for the use of multiple formats on a single page and provide a solution for creating “gorgeous looking spreadsheets very quickly.”
During my tests, I found that Numbers is, for the most part, an intuitive program that shouldnt elicit the heavy sighs and consternation that Excel has been known to do.
Read more here about why user say Numbers is the big draw to iWork 08.
However, Numbers isnt the walk in the park that Apple makes it out to be—it required a level of trial and error similar to what Ive found with Excel. That said, Numbers is a much more streamlined application than Excel.
Numbers and iWork 08 are being positioned to straddle both consumer product and enterprise markets. This incarnation of the office suite supports Office binary formats, so it will fit into any Office environment. However, there are definitely formatting kinks that need to be worked out, as well as problems exporting Numbers documents to Offices binary document for-mat.
Numbers does have OOXML support, but I found it lacking—a drawback for companies that are standardizing on Office 2007s new formats. For now, this is why Numbers will be slow to grab Google Apps steadily growing market share. Not only does Google Apps stake a claim to a no-frills, easy-to-use spreadsheet application, the Web-based documents can be shared among users.
iWork 08 is reasonably priced, at $79 (or free with the purchase of any new Mac computer). The suite requires Mac OS X version 10.4.10 or later.
Easier to navigate
Anyone who gets a migraine just thinking about creating a Microsoft Excel spreadsheet will be happy to know that Numbers is a notably less difficult application to navigate. Visually, Numbers is a veritable spitting image of Excel, so users accustomed to the Microsoft program will be pleased to see spreadsheets set up in the same way and a tool bar parroting Excel.
I found Numbers spreadsheets easy to interact with, and it was simple to organize information. Within minutes of firing up the program, I was creating spreadsheets and sorting and filtering information.
The feature I like best—and, incidentally, the one Apple is hyping the most—is Numbers intelligent tables feature, which allows users to work with multiple tables inside a single spreadsheet.
To test out this feature, I created an expense report spreadsheet similar to one used here at eWEEK. The spreadsheet I was trying to replicate can be ranked as moderate in terms of its level of formatting complexity, packed with different-sized columns and rows, various split columns and rows, and text boxes. The expense report spreadsheet also is set up so that different kinds of information occupy different areas of the spreadsheet. Sections are delineated by way of borders, a standard feature of spreadsheet programs.
To replicate this spreadsheet, I began in Numbers with a typical spreadsheet that occupied the bulk of my screen. I then resized this spreadsheet (another great feature of Numbers) so that I could free up more space to include additional blocks of information.
Rather than relying on borders to set off specific pieces of information, as the eWEEK T&E spreadsheet does, I used Numbers nifty intelligent tables feature. An intelligent table is an embedded image that resembles a miniaturized spreadsheet that can be resized to any dimension. This meant I could separate various pieces of the expense report and thereby sort, filter and change the information.
Headers and footer rows are built into the design of each intelligent table, making it very easy to designate titles and footnotes for specific pieces of the spreadsheet, instead of relying on borders or shading to do the job.
Page 2: Apple iWork 08 Provides Simple But Solid Spreadsheet App
Apple iWork 08 Provides
Simple But Solid Spreadsheet App”>
With each intelligent table, I could tweak column sizes, add and delete rows, and do pretty much anything I was able to do within the main spreadsheet. The end result was like having five different spreadsheets on one.
Still, I did have trouble splitting rows, one of the features that should have allowed me to select a row of cells and then divide those in half horizontally. I also had a hard time getting the programs borders feature to work. For example, I tried several times to add a red border to one columns left edge. Though the red border did appear, the effect caused the column to lose its grid lines, something I wasnt able to get back, even after consulting Numbers Help function.
To read more about the desktop territory gained by iWork, click here.
I also had a hard time figuring out how to replicate a few of the de-sign elements from my Excel spreadsheet into Numbers. That said, Numbers pre-designed templates are very handy and applicable to both enterprise and consumer users. Unlike other templates Ive worked with, where I have felt that much of the design was irrelevant or overly complicated, the templates in Numbers strike the right balance of structure and flexibility.
I also really liked the programs Chart function, which allowed me to select an area of information within the spreadsheet—say, from one of the intelligent tables. Then, by simply choosing a chart design, I could organize and sort the information into a pie chart or a bar graph. From there, I was able to further customize the charts look by selecting certain colors, lighting style and axis position. Numbers import and export functions didnt fare as well.
When I used Numbers to open an Excel file created in Office 2003, the page dynamics didnt translate from Excel to Numbers. The Excel spreadsheet header converted incorrectly, and information such as date and title was rearranged differently.
I next exported a file I created in Numbers. Users can export files as either a PDF or an Excel file. When I ex-ported the file as a PDF and then opened the file in Acrobat 7.0, the formatting of the original file stayed intact. However, when I attempted to export the Numbers-created file to Excel, a window notified me (and Im quoting exactly here) that an error had occurred and listed the following issues: Table names were hidden because Excel doesnt support displaying them on canvas; header and footer cells were exported as body cells, but will look the same; couldnt export pop-up menus because they arent supported in Excel (cell values were exported); and couldnt export shadow on text charts.
When I then opened this exported file in Excel 2003, the tables that appeared on one spreadsheet in Numbers were now distributed over three separate Excel spreadsheets, which made for a confusing file.
Technical Analyst Tiffany Maleshefski can be reached at [email protected].
Check out eWEEK.coms for the latest news, reviews and analysis about productivity and business solutions.