Cuil Search No Google but Getting Better
Cuil's search engine launched July 28 with designs on eating the lunches of Google, Yahoo and Microsoft. Cuil crashed back to earth when too many users tried to access it and angered Web site proprietors by showing competitors photos next to their search results. Cuil headed back into application development to tweak the search algorithm and the results have improved somewhat.Over a couple days starting with its launch July 28, Cuil gained unprecedented media attention for a startup, crashed when too many people tried to access its search engine and angered people by not putting the correct pictures with some search results.
Three weeks later it is clear that the company, which aims to one-up established search providers Google, Yahoo and Microsoft by indexing more than 120 billion Web pages and providing meaningful pictures next to search results, has made some considerable improvements with regard to the pictures it places with results.
For example, Trenton Baker, a marketing manager for network storage vendor Aberdeen LLC, told me July 29 that several of his company's industry-specific search results ended up with misused Web site photos and misleading content results.
At that time, a search for "Storage Servers" returned a news release about a product from Aberdeen rival SMC Networks. Yet the product picture Cuil gives for this result is lifted from an array on Aberdeen's front page. When you clicked on the picture link, instead of going to www.aberdeeninc.com, you were taken to the SMC press release.
Baker felt this discrepancy dinged his company's brand. Do a search on Storage Servers today and the picture next to the Aberdeen search result for networked attached storage is Aberdeen's logo for its rack-mount five-year guarantee.
The result and picture are appropriate, signaling that perhaps Cuil's context-based algorithm for providing relevant pictures alongside search results has been finer tuned.
"This is not an easy thing to do, to provide a relevant image next to as many result links as possible. Which is why this feature isn't being offered elsewhere," Cuil Vice President of Communications Vince Sollitto told me recently. "There are plenty of search engines one can use that do not attempt to provide this feature if one prefers."
Well, sure, but you don't want to tempt people to use another search engine. At least, not until you get pretty big, powerful and as close to perfection as, say, Google.
Aberdeen isn't the only company to notice the difference from July 29 and the present.
Denise Enck, proprietor of www.emptymirrorbooks.com, left this comment Aug. 3 that when searching Cuil for keywords closely related to her Web site, she found that her company's logo (and other proprietary images) appeared next to descriptions for, and links to, unrelated Web sites as well as those of competitors.
For example, a search on "beat generation books," her company's partial logo appeared with a link to the United Kingdom newspaper The Guardian. She e-mailed Cuil July 28 and July 30 until Cuil told her the issue would be resolved promptly. I circled back to Enck yesterday and asked if Cuil had improved. She wrote me:
Yes, it's improved. I really raised hell with Cuil, and though they never answered my last e-mails (sent to several individuals within the company), they did clean up their act very shortly after that. They've stopped using my logo & proprietary images to promote other people's Web sites.