Close
  • Latest News
  • Big Data and Analytics
  • Cloud
  • Networking
  • Cybersecurity
  • Applications
  • IT Management
  • Storage
  • Sponsored
  • Mobile
  • Small Business
  • Development
  • Database
  • Servers
  • Android
  • Apple
  • Innovation
  • Blogs
  • PC Hardware
  • Reviews
  • Search Engines
  • Virtualization
Read Down
Sign in
Close
Welcome!Log into your account
Forgot your password?
Read Down
Password recovery
Recover your password
Close
Search
Logo
Logo
  • Latest News
  • Big Data and Analytics
  • Cloud
  • Networking
  • Cybersecurity
  • Applications
  • IT Management
  • Storage
  • Sponsored
  • Mobile
  • Small Business
  • Development
  • Database
  • Servers
  • Android
  • Apple
  • Innovation
  • Blogs
  • PC Hardware
  • Reviews
  • Search Engines
  • Virtualization
More
    Home Latest News
    • Mobile

    Decision Delayed in BlackBerry Case; RIM Wins Round in Patent Battle

    By
    Carmen Nobel
    -
    February 24, 2006
    Share
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Linkedin

      RICHMOND, Va.—The judge charged with deciding the long-running patent-dispute case between Research In Motion and NTP on Feb. 24 failed to issue an injunction to halt BlackBerry service, but scolded the two companies for failing to settle the disagreement themselves.

      U.S. District Court Judge James Spencer said he planned to decide on whether to issue such an injunction as soon as he could, but added that a decision on damages in the case may come sooner.

      “I must say Im surprised that you have left this important and incredibly significant decision to the court,” Spencer said in a hearing on the injunction here Feb. 24. “The courts decision will be imperfect. The case shouldve been settled, but it hasnt been. So I have to deal with reality.”

      Spencer went on to say that he is inclined to stay with the jurys original decision in the case, which found that RIM had infringed on NTPs patents.

      “When all is said and done, a jury in this very courtroom decided that RIM infringed on NTPs patents and the infringement was willful,” Spencer said. “The reality of the verdict hasnt changed in any real way.”

      RIMs attorneys said they heard nothing in the courtroom that made them any more hopeful about a settlement.

      “Unfortunately, no,” said Henry Brunsow, a partner with Howrie LLP in San Francisco. “The magistrate is trying, were trying.”

      RIM has released some details of a workaround designed to keep BlackBerry users connected to the service if Spencer orders the service to shut down.

      Brunsow said in the hearing, “We do have a workaround. We can implement it. But its not something that will happen overnight. In fact, it will take quite a while…about 2 million hours.”

      Jim Balsillie, co-CEO of RIM, attended the hearing and said afterward that Brunsow meant 2 million hours total, not for each user.

      Earlier today during the trial, Balsillie noted to eWEEK that the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office gave a final rejection to the second of five NTP patents at issue in the ongoing patent infringement case that could shut down BlackBerry service.

      “Now all of NTPs claims are gone,” said Balsillie.

      A spokesperson for the USPTO confirmed that the office had issued a final rejection of the second patent.

      NTP still has three other patents related to the RIM dispute in the application process, and the USPTO spokesperson said there is no specific timetable for decision on any of the three.

      In the opening parts of the trial Feb. 24, NTP argued that it was entitled to a larger settlement due to the number of BlackBerry devices that have been rolled out since the patent dispute began.

      News of RIMs second favorable ruling from the USPTO is a positive development for the BlackBerry maker.

      On Feb. 23, the USPTO denied NTPs petition that sought to remove a Feb. 1 ruling in which the Patent Office issued a “non-final rejection” of the fifth patent at the center of the legal battle. In other words, that rejection still stands.

      Despite the patent win today, the status of RIMs service is still up to Spencer. An injunction would affect some 3 million U.S. customers. It is unclear when Spencer will issue his ruling.

      /zimages/2/28571.gifCustomers are uneasy about RIMs contingency plans. Click here to read more.

      While NTP representatives spoke the morning of Feb. 24, lawyers for RIM had yet to make their arguments that a BlackBerry shutdown would be detrimental to the public good.

      This was a sentiment echoed by the U.S. Department of Justice, which plans to have a presence at the Feb. 24 hearing, and by eBay, which is facing a similar patent infringement case.

      Lawyers for patent-holding company NTP argued that RIM should be prohibited from selling BlackBerry devices unless RIM agrees to license NTPs patents.

      The patent dispute dates back to 2001, when NTP sued the BlackBerry maker for alleged patent infringement.

      U.S. District Judge James Spencer ruled in favor of NTP in 2003, instructing RIM to halt its sales of BlackBerry devices and services in the United States until NTPs patents run out in 2012.

      Spencer stayed the ruling, however, pending appeal. Since then, the case has gone through several appeals and failed settlement attempts.

      In the meantime, the USPTO has been evaluating the validity of NTPs patents, based on prior art not considered when the patents were initially issued.

      The USPTO has indicated that it intends to reject all of NTPs claims eventually, which would render the case null and void, and RIM officials have remained publicly confident that this will happen.

      /zimages/2/28571.gifClick here for a guide to surviving a BlackBerry blackout.

      Industry experts say the process could take several months, though.

      “Despite the patent offices dedicated re-exam group, I would expect that [a ruling by the Board of Patent Appeals and Interferences]—the final agency decision—will not occur in this case until around October,” said Stephen Maebius, an attorney at Foley & Lardner LLP, in Washington, who worked at the USPTO in the early 1990s.

      To that end, Spencer has said that he does not intend to wait for the Patent Office in considering when and whether to issue an injunction.

      RIM maintains that the company has tested and readied a legal technical workaround solution that would let it continue offering its mobile e-mail service in the case of an injunction.

      Editors Note: This story was updated to include trial news and comments from a USPTO spokesperson.

      /zimages/2/28571.gifCheck out eWEEK.coms for the latest news, reviews and analysis on mobile and wireless computing.

      Carmen Nobel

      MOST POPULAR ARTICLES

      Cybersecurity

      Visa’s Michael Jabbara on Cybersecurity and Digital...

      James Maguire - May 17, 2022 0
      I spoke with Michael Jabbara, VP and Global Head of Fraud Services at Visa, about the cybersecurity technology used to ensure the safe transfer...
      Read more
      Cloud

      Yotascale CEO Asim Razzaq on Controlling Multicloud...

      James Maguire - May 5, 2022 0
      Asim Razzaq, CEO of Yotascale, provides guidance on understanding—and containing—the complex cost structure of multicloud computing. Among the topics we covered:  As you survey the...
      Read more
      Big Data and Analytics

      GoodData CEO Roman Stanek on Business Intelligence...

      James Maguire - May 4, 2022 0
      I spoke with Roman Stanek, CEO of GoodData, about business intelligence, data as a service, and the frustration that many executives have with data...
      Read more
      IT Management

      Intuit’s Nhung Ho on AI for the...

      James Maguire - May 13, 2022 0
      I spoke with Nhung Ho, Vice President of AI at Intuit, about adoption of AI in the small and medium-sized business market, and how...
      Read more
      Applications

      Cisco’s Thimaya Subaiya on Customer Experience in...

      James Maguire - May 10, 2022 0
      I spoke with Thimaya Subaiya, SVP and GM of Global Customer Experience at Cisco, about the factors that create good customer experience – and...
      Read more
      Logo

      eWeek has the latest technology news and analysis, buying guides, and product reviews for IT professionals and technology buyers. The site’s focus is on innovative solutions and covering in-depth technical content. eWeek stays on the cutting edge of technology news and IT trends through interviews and expert analysis. Gain insight from top innovators and thought leaders in the fields of IT, business, enterprise software, startups, and more.

      Facebook
      Linkedin
      RSS
      Twitter
      Youtube

      Advertisers

      Advertise with TechnologyAdvice on eWeek and our other IT-focused platforms.

      Advertise with Us

      Menu

      • About eWeek
      • Subscribe to our Newsletter
      • Latest News

      Our Brands

      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms
      • About
      • Contact
      • Advertise
      • Sitemap
      • California – Do Not Sell My Information

      Property of TechnologyAdvice.
      © 2021 TechnologyAdvice. All Rights Reserved

      Advertiser Disclosure: Some of the products that appear on this site are from companies from which TechnologyAdvice receives compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site including, for example, the order in which they appear. TechnologyAdvice does not include all companies or all types of products available in the marketplace.

      ×