eWEEK content and product recommendations are editorially independent. We may make money when you click on links to our partners. Learn More.
After spending the last five days using the Samsung Nexus 4G smartphone, which Sprint began selling May 8 for $199.99 on contract, I’m experiencing some serious cognitive dissonance.
I love the phone’s hardware and software, but I am not crazy about Sprint’s 4G WiMAX network. The Nexus S 4G is certainly faster than the original Nexus S Google launched last December on T-Mobile’s network.
However, I used the new Nexus after testing both the HTC ThunderBolt 4G and Samsung Droid Charge on Verizon Wireless’ 4G LTE (Long-Term Evolution) network. If you’re guessing Verizon won that race, you’d be right.
Sprint does offer something with the Nexus S 4G that could win a lot of people over: native Google Voice support. Google Voice on this phone is great, and you won’t find that on Verizon, AT&T, T-Mobile or any other carrier right now.
Let’s back up to gloss over the hardware and software. The Nexus S 4G is its Nexus S predecessor in all external aesthetic and most internal aspects, but it’s powered by a 4G radio inside instead a 3G transmitter.
The 1GHz processor-powered phone features a pretty 4-inch Super AMOLED (Super active-matrix organic LED) display (480 by 800 resolution), which was the best screen I ever tested until the Droid Charge came along with its 4.3-inch Super AMOLED Plus screen. That phone went on sale May 14.
When I tested the Nexus S last December, I believed it to be Samsung’s best hardware to date. After testing the Motorola Atrix 4G, HTC ThunderBolt and Droid Charge this year, all those phones felt more comfortable in my hand.
As I held the Nexus S 4G, which measures 4.8 inches long, 2.5 inches wide and less than half an inch thick, it occurred to me the black bezeled plastic is nice but a little slick in my hand, compared with the more pedestrian, tough-guy gray plastic of the Charge. I kept thinking I would drop it, even if I never did.
I could argue that the Nexus S 4G’s software is superior; the phone runs Android 2.3 “Gingerbread,” while inexplicably, the Charge runs Android 2.2 despite a price tag of $299.99.
Honestly, other than the better virtual keyboard and one-touch copy-and-paste functionality afforded by Gingerbread on Sprint’s new gadget, I don’t notice much difference. See more about the Gingerbread specs here.
I’m not a big gamer, so the gyroscope is not a big deal for me. And while Gingerbread’s NFC (near-field communication) capabilities are great in theory, they are weak in practice. No one is using NFC in a meaningful way to a great degree. Heck, Apple is even bailing on it for the next iPhone.
Call quality on the Nexus S 4G is fine and the 5MP camera and front-facing VGA camera are serviceable, if unspectacular, for photo- and video-taking. There’s also 16GB of iNAND internal storage.
Sprints Nexus S 4G Is Fast but Not Verizon 4G LTE Fast
Sprint claims up to 10M bps for its WiMAX on the Nexus S 4G. Sprint’s WiMax is not available here in my home state of Connecticut, but I accessed it easily enough while visiting family in Westchester County, New York.
I received an average of 4M bps upload speeds and 5M bps download speeds. Faster than 3G? Oh yeah, but Sprint’s WiMAX network is no match for Verizon’s 4G LTE network, at least where I tested it.
For the Droid Charge, I saw anywhere from 4 to 11M bps download speeds and upload speeds of 3 to 5M bps, androughly 5 to 11-plus megabits per second download speeds and 2 to 4-plus megabits per second upload speeds for the ThunderBolt.
However, like those 4G phones, the Nexus S 4G’s 1,500mAh battery burned down so quickly the phone needed a charge after 3 hours on consistent 4G use in New York. That’s not going to cut it. Of course, I had a car charger, but what if I hadn’t brought it? I’d be out of luck.
What’s interesting about this is that this phone uses the same battery as its 3G predecessor, which lasted a full day, according to my review of that device last Christmas season.
As a “pure Google experience” Android phone, the Nexus S 4G offers out-of-the-box Google Search and Voice Search, Voice Actions, Gmail, Google Calendar, Google Earth, Google Maps with Navigation, Google Talk and YouTube. Android Market now boasts 200,000 applications.
For my mobile phone needs, Google Voice is the game-changer on the Nexus S 4G, allowing users to use their existing Sprint number as their Google Voice number to ring any phones when people call their mobile phone.
Users may also choose to replace their existing Sprint number with their mobile Google Voice number. This means all calls and texts sent from a user’s Sprint smartphone will display their Google Voice number to recipients of calls and messages.
This also means Sprint phone users won’t incur porting charges and service disruptions. Calls from Gmail and text messages sent from Google Voice will display users’ Sprint number. All of this worked beautifully and seamlessly for me, right down to the funky, off-kilter Google Voice message transcriptions.
I came away from the Nexus S 4G satisfied that it offers a better user experience than the original 3G Nexus S, but not thrilled enough by Sprint’s WiMAX network that I would leave Verizon’s 4G LTE network for it.
With the Droid Charge and ThunderBolt, and Galaxy S II devices on the way to leverage Verizon’s superior network, I’m sticking with the leader despite Sprint’s great Google Voice experience. If you’re a Sprint user and want to stay on network with a speedier phone, the Nexus S 4G is a great choice.
