Close
  • Latest News
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Video
  • Big Data and Analytics
  • Cloud
  • Networking
  • Cybersecurity
  • Applications
  • IT Management
  • Storage
  • Sponsored
  • Mobile
  • Small Business
  • Development
  • Database
  • Servers
  • Android
  • Apple
  • Innovation
  • Blogs
  • PC Hardware
  • Reviews
  • Search Engines
  • Virtualization
Read Down
Sign in
Close
Welcome!Log into your account
Forgot your password?
Read Down
Password recovery
Recover your password
Close
Search
Logo
Subscribe
Logo
  • Latest News
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Video
  • Big Data and Analytics
  • Cloud
  • Networking
  • Cybersecurity
  • Applications
  • IT Management
  • Storage
  • Sponsored
  • Mobile
  • Small Business
  • Development
  • Database
  • Servers
  • Android
  • Apple
  • Innovation
  • Blogs
  • PC Hardware
  • Reviews
  • Search Engines
  • Virtualization
More
    Subscribe
    Home Latest News
    • Mobile

    Wi-LAN vs. Cisco: The Lawyers View

    Written by

    Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
    Published June 28, 2004
    Share
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Linkedin

      eWEEK content and product recommendations are editorially independent. We may make money when you click on links to our partners. Learn More.

      Wi-LAN Inc.s suit against industry giant Cisco Systems Inc. over Wi-Fi patent infringements will be a difficult one to win, according to intellectual property attorneys.

      The Calgary, Alberta-based wireless equipment manufacturers Canadian and U.S. patents cover OFDM (orthogonal frequency division multiplexing). This modulation technique is used in the popular 802.11g and 802.11a IEEE Wi-Fi standards to enable their high-speed networking.

      Cisco is being singled out for Wi-LANs legal ire because “we wanted a big name because they [Cisco] are selling more than anyone else,” Sayed-Amr El-Hamamsy, president and CEO of Wi-LAN, told eWEEK in an earlier interview. “It seems like people will not even have a negotiation with you until you turn nasty. Now, its time to seek whats rightfully ours.”

      /zimages/2/28571.gifFor more on the Wi-LAN suit, click here.

      Cisco is currently examining its options. “Wi-LAN claims that its patents are related to industry standards and appears to be applying the patents to the Wi-Fi industry as a whole. We will respond as appropriate after reviewing the claims, ” said Penny Bruce, a Cisco spokesperson.

      Kenneth Allen, IP (intellectual property) attorney and partner in the Palo Alto, Calif., office of Townsend and Townsend and Crew LLP, thinks Wi-LAN may have trouble proving its claims. “Anyone who claims to own fundamental patents has a high wall to climb to establish credibility, especially in a field where the technology is not fundamentally new. For example, frequency-hopping spread-spectrum wireless modem techniques have been used for years in robust proprietary wireless data networks preceding the 802.11x standards, such as the Ricochet Network developed by Metricom.

      “The Wi-Fi field is not based on new principles; it uses techniques that a large group of users must agree upon in order to promote its widespread use,” Allen said. “Typically, claimed inventions are combinations of old technologies used in a new way. Nevertheless, the claims of the various patents will need to be considered to determine if the marketing promotions have any credence and if they actually do cover the adopted standards. If that is the case, then it is expected that the patents will be licensed on a reasonable and nondiscriminatory basis that is fair to all.”

      Indeed, as Kelly Talcott, an IP attorney and partner at Kirkpatrick & Lockhart LLPs New York office, pointed out, “802.11a, b and g are all IEEE-based standards. In connection therewith, various companies file assurance letters with the IEEE in accordance with the bylaws of the IEEE Standards Board.”

      These LoAs (letters of assurances) make it clear that an IEEE standard “may include the known use of essential patents and patent applications.”

      But, these LoAs must include either “a general disclaimer to the effect that the patentee will not enforce any of its present or future patent(s) whose use would be required to implement either mandatory or optional portions of the proposed IEEE standard against any person or entity complying with the standard; or b) a statement that a license for such implementation will be made available without compensation or under reasonable rates, with reasonable terms and conditions that are demonstrably free of any unfair discrimination. This assurance shall apply, at a minimum, from the date of the standards approval to the date of the standards withdrawal and is irrevocable during that period.”

      Wi-LAN has filed three such LoAs for each of the three widely used Wi-Fi 802.11 standards.

      Wi-LAN, however, withdrew its assurances for 802.11b “in 14 Sept. (1998) letter to the extent that 7 July (1998) letter implies US Pat 5,555,268 is necessary to conform with standard.” Talcott observed, “Wi-LAN is one of the very few who have filed such letters and chose to expressly limit their scope.”

      While not venturing an opinion on how Wi-LAN will fare in the court system, Talcott noted that “Wi-LANs suit demonstrates the tension that exists when an industry standard is alleged to infringe one or more patents held by a third party. You have on the one hand the common interest in developing a market for interoperable devices and, on the other hand, the public policy that encourages invention by protecting a patent holders right to exploit the invention during the patent term.”

      /zimages/2/28571.gifCheck out eWEEK.coms Mobile & Wireless Center at http://wireless.eweek.com for the latest news, reviews and analysis.

      /zimages/2/77042.gif

      Be sure to add our eWEEK.com mobile and wireless news feed to your RSS newsreader or My Yahoo page

      Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
      Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols
      I'm editor-at-large for Ziff Davis Enterprise. That's a fancy title that means I write about whatever topic strikes my fancy or needs written about across the Ziff Davis Enterprise family of publications. You'll find most of my stories in Linux-Watch, DesktopLinux and eWEEK. Prior to becoming a technology journalist, I worked at NASA and the Department of Defense on numerous major technological projects.

      Get the Free Newsletter!

      Subscribe to Daily Tech Insider for top news, trends & analysis

      Get the Free Newsletter!

      Subscribe to Daily Tech Insider for top news, trends & analysis

      MOST POPULAR ARTICLES

      Artificial Intelligence

      9 Best AI 3D Generators You Need...

      Sam Rinko - June 25, 2024 0
      AI 3D Generators are powerful tools for many different industries. Discover the best AI 3D Generators, and learn which is best for your specific use case.
      Read more
      Cloud

      RingCentral Expands Its Collaboration Platform

      Zeus Kerravala - November 22, 2023 0
      RingCentral adds AI-enabled contact center and hybrid event products to its suite of collaboration services.
      Read more
      Artificial Intelligence

      8 Best AI Data Analytics Software &...

      Aminu Abdullahi - January 18, 2024 0
      Learn the top AI data analytics software to use. Compare AI data analytics solutions & features to make the best choice for your business.
      Read more
      Latest News

      Zeus Kerravala on Networking: Multicloud, 5G, and...

      James Maguire - December 16, 2022 0
      I spoke with Zeus Kerravala, industry analyst at ZK Research, about the rapid changes in enterprise networking, as tech advances and digital transformation prompt...
      Read more
      Video

      Datadog President Amit Agarwal on Trends in...

      James Maguire - November 11, 2022 0
      I spoke with Amit Agarwal, President of Datadog, about infrastructure observability, from current trends to key challenges to the future of this rapidly growing...
      Read more
      Logo

      eWeek has the latest technology news and analysis, buying guides, and product reviews for IT professionals and technology buyers. The site’s focus is on innovative solutions and covering in-depth technical content. eWeek stays on the cutting edge of technology news and IT trends through interviews and expert analysis. Gain insight from top innovators and thought leaders in the fields of IT, business, enterprise software, startups, and more.

      Facebook
      Linkedin
      RSS
      Twitter
      Youtube

      Advertisers

      Advertise with TechnologyAdvice on eWeek and our other IT-focused platforms.

      Advertise with Us

      Menu

      • About eWeek
      • Subscribe to our Newsletter
      • Latest News

      Our Brands

      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms
      • About
      • Contact
      • Advertise
      • Sitemap
      • California – Do Not Sell My Information

      Property of TechnologyAdvice.
      © 2024 TechnologyAdvice. All Rights Reserved

      Advertiser Disclosure: Some of the products that appear on this site are from companies from which TechnologyAdvice receives compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site including, for example, the order in which they appear. TechnologyAdvice does not include all companies or all types of products available in the marketplace.