Close
  • Latest News
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Video
  • Big Data and Analytics
  • Cloud
  • Networking
  • Cybersecurity
  • Applications
  • IT Management
  • Storage
  • Sponsored
  • Mobile
  • Small Business
  • Development
  • Database
  • Servers
  • Android
  • Apple
  • Innovation
  • Blogs
  • PC Hardware
  • Reviews
  • Search Engines
  • Virtualization
Read Down
Sign in
Close
Welcome!Log into your account
Forgot your password?
Read Down
Password recovery
Recover your password
Close
Search
Logo
Subscribe
Logo
  • Latest News
  • Artificial Intelligence
  • Video
  • Big Data and Analytics
  • Cloud
  • Networking
  • Cybersecurity
  • Applications
  • IT Management
  • Storage
  • Sponsored
  • Mobile
  • Small Business
  • Development
  • Database
  • Servers
  • Android
  • Apple
  • Innovation
  • Blogs
  • PC Hardware
  • Reviews
  • Search Engines
  • Virtualization
More
    Subscribe
    Home IT Management
    • IT Management
    • Networking

    Federal Court Denies Minnesotas Bid to Regulate VOIP

    Written by

    Wayne Rash
    Published March 22, 2007
    Share
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Linkedin

      eWEEK content and product recommendations are editorially independent. We may make money when you click on links to our partners. Learn More.

      The United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit in Minneapolis has blocked the State of Minnesotas effort to regulate voice over IP telephony provider Vonage.

      In a decision handed down March 21, the court agreed with Vonage and with the Federal Communications Commission that Vonage and IP phone companies like it are inherently interstate in nature, and as a result are not subject to state regulation.

      The court also agreed that the FCC had the right to preempt state laws that would attempt to regulate, tax or otherwise impede the operation of such Internet-based voice telephony services.

      However, the court stopped short of saying the same rules would apply to cable-based IP telephony services, saying that those are not yet ripe for review.

      By that, the court meant that no legal actions have been filed by states attempting to regulate cable-based VOIP (voice over IP) services, and as a result there were no legal decisions that could be reviewed.

      However, the court did note that if such an attempt were made, the FCC had already said that it would exert its preemption there as well.

      As a part of its decision, the court made it clear that VOIP services were by their nature an “information service,” and therefore excluded from state regulation.

      The court also noted that because it was impossible to know where a VOIP call originated, it was also impossible for a state to prove that it was operating within the state that was trying to regulate it.

      In this, the court said that the case was very similar to other circuit court decisions, notably the National Cable & Telecommunications Association vs. Gulf Power, where the courts decided that it would be impossible to tell if the communications in any particular instance was interstate or intrastate.

      The court also said that Minnesotas contentions that the FCC had acted arbitrarily were incorrect, pointing out that the FCC had said in previous cases that Internet communications were very different from circuit-switched telephone calls.

      Then the court pointed out that the FCC was the real authority in this area anyway.

      “Because of the high level of deference we owe to the FCC in this fact-specific issue, it is unnecessary to justify our decision by countering all of the petitioners challenges to the FCCs fact-findings.”

      The court also said that the FCC requirement that VOIP providers be required to provide Enhanced 911 data did not make them subject to state regulation.

      In fact, the court found that the requirement that this data be specifically provided by the phone company showed that otherwise location was in doubt.

      “The FCC did not arbitrarily or capriciously preempt Minnesotas 911 requirements,” the court said.

      The Minnesota case was combined with similar suits by the state of Ohio, The National Association of State Utility Consumer Advocates and the National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners.

      The New York Public Utility Commission brought the suit regarding cable providers and VOIP that the court decided was not ripe for review.

      “It wasnt a big surprise,” said David Kaut, associate analyst for the financial research firm of Stifel, Nicolaus in Washington, D.C.

      “People thought the FCC was going to win on Vonage,” he said. Kaut pointed out that its impossible to know for sure where a Vonage user actually is when a phone call is being made. “If you cant unscramble that egg, the answer is to declare it predominately interstate.”

      Click here

      to read more about the FCCs court actions regarding Web phone services.

      Kaut noted that the decision is only binding on the area served by the Eighth Circuit. However, he said its a powerful precedent for other circuits.

      He also noted that the only hope Minnesota has now is to appeal it to the US Supreme Court, a path he says is unlikely.

      “I think its an uphill battle,” Kaut said. “The Supreme Court only takes 80 cases a year,” he noted, suggesting that this was unlikely to be one of them.

      Kaut noted that a decision on cable companies offering VOIP service was bound to come along fairly soon.

      He said that the Missouri Public Service Commission was already trying to regulate cable-based VOIP service, but that the case hasnt reached the federal courts.

      “If the FCC doesnt weigh in on this classification, they may find trouble on this where the courts have defined it,” he said.

      But at this point, he noted, its the squeaky wheel that gets the attention, and that this case hadnt reached that level.

      “The FCC has been concerned about jumping off that bridge,” he said.

      Check out eWEEK.coms for the latest news, views and analysis on voice over IP and telephony.

      Wayne Rash
      Wayne Rash
      https://www.eweek.com/author/wayne-rash/
      Wayne Rash is a content writer and editor with a 35-year history covering technology. He’s a frequent speaker on business, technology issues and enterprise computing. He is the author of five books, including his most recent, "Politics on the Nets." Rash is a former Executive Editor of eWEEK and a former analyst in the eWEEK Test Center. He was also an analyst in the InfoWorld Test Center and editor of InternetWeek. He's a retired naval officer, a former principal at American Management Systems and a long-time columnist for Byte Magazine.

      Get the Free Newsletter!

      Subscribe to Daily Tech Insider for top news, trends & analysis

      Get the Free Newsletter!

      Subscribe to Daily Tech Insider for top news, trends & analysis

      MOST POPULAR ARTICLES

      Artificial Intelligence

      9 Best AI 3D Generators You Need...

      Sam Rinko - June 25, 2024 0
      AI 3D Generators are powerful tools for many different industries. Discover the best AI 3D Generators, and learn which is best for your specific use case.
      Read more
      Cloud

      RingCentral Expands Its Collaboration Platform

      Zeus Kerravala - November 22, 2023 0
      RingCentral adds AI-enabled contact center and hybrid event products to its suite of collaboration services.
      Read more
      Artificial Intelligence

      8 Best AI Data Analytics Software &...

      Aminu Abdullahi - January 18, 2024 0
      Learn the top AI data analytics software to use. Compare AI data analytics solutions & features to make the best choice for your business.
      Read more
      Latest News

      Zeus Kerravala on Networking: Multicloud, 5G, and...

      James Maguire - December 16, 2022 0
      I spoke with Zeus Kerravala, industry analyst at ZK Research, about the rapid changes in enterprise networking, as tech advances and digital transformation prompt...
      Read more
      Video

      Datadog President Amit Agarwal on Trends in...

      James Maguire - November 11, 2022 0
      I spoke with Amit Agarwal, President of Datadog, about infrastructure observability, from current trends to key challenges to the future of this rapidly growing...
      Read more
      Logo

      eWeek has the latest technology news and analysis, buying guides, and product reviews for IT professionals and technology buyers. The site’s focus is on innovative solutions and covering in-depth technical content. eWeek stays on the cutting edge of technology news and IT trends through interviews and expert analysis. Gain insight from top innovators and thought leaders in the fields of IT, business, enterprise software, startups, and more.

      Facebook
      Linkedin
      RSS
      Twitter
      Youtube

      Advertisers

      Advertise with TechnologyAdvice on eWeek and our other IT-focused platforms.

      Advertise with Us

      Menu

      • About eWeek
      • Subscribe to our Newsletter
      • Latest News

      Our Brands

      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms
      • About
      • Contact
      • Advertise
      • Sitemap
      • California – Do Not Sell My Information

      Property of TechnologyAdvice.
      © 2024 TechnologyAdvice. All Rights Reserved

      Advertiser Disclosure: Some of the products that appear on this site are from companies from which TechnologyAdvice receives compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site including, for example, the order in which they appear. TechnologyAdvice does not include all companies or all types of products available in the marketplace.