Readers Debate Microsoft Bing vs. Google with Religious Fervor

Readers respond with vitriol and some common sense in their comments comparing Microsoft's Bing search engine to Google's goliath search engine. The debate is heated and recalls the Windows vs. Linux and Firefox vs. Internet Explorer crusades from the last several years. What side are you on, or is the jury still out in your mind?

In case people hadn't noticed, there is a new holy war boiling up from the land of Web search engines. Microsoft's Bing search engine has only been public for more than a month and it is already drawing comparisons to Google's leading search engine.

Comparisons between Google and Microsoft are not new. Users, pundits and other experts have been comparing Google Apps to Microsoft's Office and SharePoint applications for the last few years. Microsoft has offered various iterations of Web search to counter Google for years, but no one has taken the software giant's search overtures seriously. That is, until Bing arrived.

From the birth of Bing in June until now, it has become increasingly clear there is a new crusade afoot, something to perhaps rival the Linux versus Microsoft Windows or Firefox versus Microsoft Internet Explorer battles the world has watched evolve for the last decade or so.

The aesthetic differences are marked. Google, at 10 years old, is a stalwart of simplicity. The Google search box is as iconic as it is nondescript, bringing users 10 blue links and more. Microsoft Bing is beautiful, offering a screensaver-like background and, by most accounts so far, very much the same search experience.

Reports from StatCounter and others claims Bing has been pickingup some search market share in the United States, thanks largely to the buzz generated from Microsoft's $80 million marketing and public relations campaign. However, Web design firm Catalyst Group found that most users were unwilling to leave the comfortable confines of Google for upstart Bing.

eWEEK readers responded passionately to these news items, weighing in not only on how they find Bing and Google, but what they think will happen to both products in the future. These readers often chose not to issue their real names, and in some cases provided no names, for their submissions so bear with the nomenclature. Anonymous Reader No. 1 wrote:

"For starters, I wouldn't use BING if it were the only search engine left on the Internet. The fact that it came from Microsoft is reason enough for me not to use it. But that aside... curiosity did get the best of me, and I did play with it. I wasn't a fan of the site. The relevance of the results were grossly hit and miss for me. Not only that, but the added "visual flare" only served to distract. Add to that the fact that I don't spend large consecutive blocks of time at any given search engine. With that said, excess search engine graphics simply serve to get in the way. But that aside, people love to stick with what they know. Many of us know exactly how to coerce Google into giving us the results we want. It's fast, it's clean and it's to the point. That's why I use it over Yahoo, Bing and all the other search engines out there."

Anonymous Reader No. 2 made a reasonable rational argument... once one gets past the obvious disgust for anything Microsoft, an old, old argument that forces others to dismiss such comments out of hand. Anonymous Reader No. 2 threw Anonymous Reader No. 1's words back into the mix:

"For starters, I wouldn't use BING if it were the only search engine left on the Internet. The fact that it came from Microsoft is reason enough for me not to use it." That's because you are a BoneHead... I'll bet you are typing on a Windows computer right now. Why? Because it's the best OS for the money, bar none. And that includes the FREE Linux. People like to bash Microsoft because they are competitive and successful, and they make the best products. Granted, there is a lot of good Open Source software out there, but if you REALLY want to get your work done productively (sic), it's done on Microsoft Products. And yes, I've used them ALL extensively. I've been working on and using computers since the first Apples, TI's, Tandy's, Commodores, etc, and I've tried everything else along the way."

Anonymous Reader No. 3 also chimed in to bash Microsoft: "Microsoft needs to stop trying to catch Google and its search engine market share and concentrate on what it does best...designing PC operating Systems. Oh wait, Microsoft hasn't been doing good there either. Oh well. There's always Xbox!"