Linux Desktop Developers Find Common Ground

News Analysis: A developer meeting strengthens a Linux desktop alliance that could lead to better leverage with hardware vendors and more cross-distribution efforts such as the newly created Portland Project.

Open Source Development Labs Inc. this weekend called together architects from over two dozen key desktop-oriented Linux projects to work out their differences and to find common cause in their efforts to create the best possible Linux desktop.

From all reports, the OSDL-sponsored meeting was a success.

Perhaps the biggest accomplishment of the meeting was that the attendees realized how much they had in common.

According to John Cherry, OSDLs Initiative manager for the Linux desktop, people finally understood that "weve got to stop acting like a bunch of disparate organizations and work together on the Linux desktop for it to be successful."

Even organizations that had often squabbled with each other over which had the better view for the Linux desktops future, such as the KDE Project and the GNOME Foundation, got along well.

"It was fun to watch talking Gnome and KDE developers actually getting together and having fun," Cherry said.

As "an outsider, a non-developer, it was exciting to see the industry maturing in front of us. To see people realizing that they need each other to make things work," said Dave Rosenberg, OSDLs principal analyst.

In addition, developers realized that by working together they will have more of a consolidated voice in talking with hardware vendors, which will help "make more progress with vendors in getting the code needed to make progress with hardware drivers," Cherry said.

Getting the needed APIs and ABIs (application binary interfaces) for many devices has long been a sticking point for Linux attempts to equal Windows support for many desktop devices.

/zimages/1/28571.gifClick here to read more about what vendor support could do for the Linux desktop.

The most concrete result from the meeting, however, was the creation of the Portland Project.

"Portland will provide a common set of Linux desktop interfaces that allows applications to easily integrate with the Linux desktop that the end user or his organization has chosen to work with," said Waldo Bastian, a KDE engineer and a FreeDesktop leader.

"The great thing about this is that application developers can choose a Linux tool kit to develop with based on the characteristics of the tool kit that best fits their business goals, without having to worry about which flavor of Linux desktop [the companys] customers are using," Bastian added.

In other words, Portlands goal is to make it possible for desktop software developers to write to the Linux desktop without having to worry about whether the distribution or user is using KDE, GNOME or a more obscure Linux desktop.

Since the goals of Portland are very much in line with the mission of, it was agreed that was the proper place to drive this effort.

Unlike the end-user-oriented Tango Desktop Project, where the idea is to create a consistent user experience on Linux desktops, Portland is designed to make it easier for ISVs to port their applications to the Linux desktop without worrying about the interface.

According to Bastian, "To speed up the process, a task force of four people will be created, with two representatives from both GNOME and KDE. Alex Graveley [of GNOME] and George Staikos [of KDE] agreed to lead the task force and will each invite one additional member."

"The goal of the task force is to prioritize integration points, solicit feedback from ISVs and identify existing functionality in Gnome and KDE that can be used to implement Portland and possibly provide a first draft implementation," Bastian said.

"The goal is to have the first version of Portland ready for inclusion in LSB (Linux Standard Base) 4.0, which is scheduled for the end of 2006."

The desktop developers plan to get together again in May of 2006 to continue with their work of finding common ground for the best possible Linux desktop.

/zimages/1/28571.gifCheck out eWEEK.coms for the latest open-source news, reviews and analysis.