OSDL Turns Down Microsofts Study Offer

Microsoft offers to co-sponsor a Linux vs. Windows study with the OSDL, but the OSDL says thanks, but no thanks.

At LinuxWorld Conference & Expo this August, Microsoft approached the Open Source Development Labs about conducting a jointly funded research study to compare and contrast Windows and Linux. OSDLs head turned Microsoft down flat.

In a recent statement, OSDL (Open Source Development Labs) CEO Stuart Cohen said that he had nixed the offer from Microsoft.

"As far as working with Microsoft on a study, I explained that Microsoft could probably find one negative line on Linux in a 100-page research report that it would spend $10 million marketing while ignoring the other 99 pages," he said. "Why would OSDL want to participate in that?"

When the story that Microsofts Martin Taylor, the architect of Microsofts anti-Linux "Get the Facts" campaign and the Redmond, Wash., software firms general manager of platform strategy, proposed to Cohen that the two join forces on a co-sponsored study, many found it hard to believe.

The OSDL, employer of Linus Torvalds, Linuxs founder, is a leading pro-Linux organization. Its membership list is a whos who of Linux companies such as Red Hat Inc., Novell Inc. and Turbolinux.

/zimages/6/28571.gifRead more here about Novell joining OSDL.

Others doubted that Microsoft could be serious since the two had dynamically opposed positions on the merits and flaws of the operating systems.

Taylor said he sent Cohen, at OSDLs Beaverton, Ore., headquarters, an e-mail ahead of the annual LinuxWorld Conference in San Francisco earlier this month, suggesting the idea and asking for a meeting.

The two then met at LinuxWorld and discussed the idea and how it would work it broad terms, but there was no agreement of any sort,

The OSDL leadership, at first, had little to say about the matter.

"Stuart Cohen did receive a request from Martin Taylor at Microsoft before Linux World. In part, Martin said he was interested in talking with Stuart about joint research opportunities on some of the issues in the market. Stuart agreed to meet with Martin and they did meet," was all a spokesperson said.

/zimages/6/28571.gifTo read more about open source from columnist Steven J. Vaughan-Nichols, click here.

Recently, however, in the statement from OSDL, Cohen was more explicit.

Martin proposed that our meeting stay confidential in order to be as productive as possible, and I agreed," said Cohen.

"When reporters contacted me about the meeting, I first asked Martin how he wanted us to respond to questions about a confidential conversation. He said hes looking into how the press was notified, and he promised to get back to me," Cohen said.

Meanwhile, the study is off.

Editors Note: This story was updated to highlight the OSDLs rejection of Microsofts offer for a joint study.

/zimages/6/28571.gifCheck out eWEEK.coms for the latest open-source news, reviews and analysis.